Susan Dalgety: Rebuild Westminster Parliament – what could possibly go wrong!

One of the most recognisable public buildings in the world is falling to bits. The Houses of Parliament – or the Palace of Westminster to give them their Sunday name – need urgent work if they are not to crumble into the Thames.

Despite being a relatively new building in British terms – it was built between 1840 and 1870 after the original medieval palace was destroyed by fire in 1834, leaving only Westminster Hall intact – both the House of Lords and the House of Commons are now considered a safety risk.

Parliament revamp could cost £40bn and take 61 yearsplaceholder image
Parliament revamp could cost £40bn and take 61 years

The most pressing concern is the antique wiring - the whole place needs a rewire before there is a major fire. The roofs leak and the structural metalwork which forms the buildings’ skeleton is corroded.

There are large amounts of asbestos; hundreds, if not thousands of mice running amok, and the complex was not designed for the telephone era, let alone the digital one.

A report last week says it could cost £40 billion and take up to 60 years to bring the buildings up to an acceptable standard if MPs stayed put during the work, moving into the Lords while the House of Commons was sorted.

A second option, which would see all the politicians and their staff decanting to nearby buildings, would come in at £15 billion and take ‘only’ up to 25 years.

Whatever MPs and Lords decide, they would do well to take advice from Scotland first. Twenty five years ago, this newspaper was instrumental in revealing the delays and spiralling costs of the Scottish Parliament which eventually led to a public inquiry.

Its chair, Lord Fraser, found that the Holyrood building was a very expensive failure of project management, including poor cost control, inadequate risk management and weak governance.

MPs are not construction experts. A project of the size and scale of the Westminster refurbishment needs the best possible technical expertise to bring it in on time and on budget.

And it needs independent experts in charge, not a committee of MPs, Lords and civil servants who, with the best will in the world, are not qualified to oversee such a complex project.

Holyrood stands as a warning, but will they listen?

News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice