The city council’s tram extension thinking is on a wayward path - Steve Cardownie

I make no apologies for returning to the subject of the proposed North to South Edinburgh tram line extension, as this issue in particular is set to dominate the headlines.

Last week I commented on the Edinburgh City Council’s SNP Group’s policy switch and had now come out against the potential two routes under consideration from the city centre to Granton.

The popular Roseburn Path is one of two route options being considered for the tramline extension to Granton, but opposition to it has been growing. Picture: Lisa Fergusonplaceholder image
The popular Roseburn Path is one of two route options being considered for the tramline extension to Granton, but opposition to it has been growing. Picture: Lisa Ferguson

One potential route entails significant construction on what is known as the “Roseburn Path” and the other under consideration is that over the Dean Bridge. A strategic “Business Case” is to be put before councillors in September- but will it be worth the paper it is written on?

The Liberal Democrat Group on the Council has said that it will not support the “Roseburn Path” option and with 14 councillors in their Group their views carry some weight.

Add to this the SNP’s newfound opposition to the “Roseburn Path” with 17 councillors, means that 31 councillors out of the 63 that make up the Council have already ruled out that option.

Now, the Conservative Group, with 10 councillors, has also cast doubt on the whole project, with their Group Leader, Councillor Iain Whyte, quoted as saying that “Neither government has come up with the money….until you get some guarantee of funding, the whole thing is fantasy.”

Tellingly, reporter Ian Swanson of The Evening News, wrote last week that “But now the local SNP’s position to the Roseburn Path has received national backing in the party’s manifesto, (for May’s Scottish Parliament election-SC) though the document stops short of backing the tramline, which the Scottish Government has said there is no money for.”

So, not only is the SNP at Holyrood setting its face against the “Roseburn Path” it has also declined to commit any funding for the whole project. The only way I can see this possibly changing is that if there is a “hung” parliament after the May 7th election and the Greens demand that funding the tram extension be the price to be paid to enlist their support of an SNP Government, which is unlikely- and that the SNP agrees to do so.

City Council Green Group Councillor, Chas Booth, wrote to this paper and corrected my assumption that the Green Group was opposed to the “Roseburn Path” option writing that,

“We believe that it would be premature to rule out any option before the consultation report is published. We will consider that report carefully and continue to listen to residents and stakeholders before reaching a view on the best route.”

So, as far as the Green Group on the Council (with 11 councillors) is concerned, the “Roseburn Path” option is worthy of consideration - which will surely raise some eyebrows amongst their supporters- it certainly raised mine!

All things considered, it would appear to me that, as the Conservative Group opposed the tram extension to Newhaven and that they have consistently poured scorn on the new extension plans, their number can be safely added to those who have already stated their opposition to the “Roseburn Path” taking it up to 41 councillors out of the 63 against that option at least.

So, consultants will be working up proposals for an option that is dead in the water. Why not issue new instructions?

This is already proving to be “the Klondike” for consultants.

Related topics:
News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice