The last brutalist building standing faces a timely end - Kevin Buckle

Given all that has gone before, I should not really have been surprised to read that plans to demolish Argyle House, the ugly office block on Lady Lawson Street that architects like to call brutalist, was being challenged by an application to give it listed status by Historic Environment Scotland.

The Architectural Heritage Society of Scotland (AHSS), the organisation that raises awareness about Scotland's 20th- century historic environment and the Twentieth Century Society have made the application.

Planners at Edinburgh council have received a Proposal of Application Notice (PAN) for demolition of Argyle House in Castle Terraceplaceholder image
Planners at Edinburgh council have received a Proposal of Application Notice (PAN) for demolition of Argyle House in Castle Terrace

Of course, it wasn’t that long ago that the car park on King’s Stables Road was saved from a similar fate by also being listed as an important brutalist building.

The thing about brutalist buildings is that most of them have been demolished over the years on the simple basis they look awful. However, we have now reached a point where the argument is that a brutalist building should remain standing because it is one of the last of its kind.

When I was asked by the council to be a consultant on the sale of the buildings they owned at the Grassmarket end of King’s Stables Road I was told that in a perfect world, as well as these buildings being redeveloped to provide some interesting shops and restaurants, the council-owned car park next door would be developed too and the wish was that though not owned by the council that nearby Argyle House on Lady Lawson Street would also be demolished.

I received contact from several other consultants who had given their opinion on both improving the footfall in the area and on what could be put in place of what was quite a large area, even if Argyle House was not involved.

Having said there had to be an interesting offering as people left the Grassmarket to walk down King’s Stables Road, the council instead went with a developer who built student flats and a hotel on the site, exactly what I had been told was not needed. And in a final irony the building with lovely arch windows the architects had earmarked for being a nice restaurant became an architects practice!

Again with the lease on the car park about to expire it seemed a no-brainer that the council would not renew it, given their wish to reduce the number of cars coming into the city centre. It then turned out that parts of the car park had been declared dangerous with crumbling concrete, so its demolition seemed a done deal. However in stepped the HES, Historic Environment Scotland, to designate it a listed building.

At the time Elizabeth McCrone of HES said the brutalist car park "not only had a hugely innovative design" but was "carefully conceived not to interfere with views of Edinburgh Castle".

It was described as having a brutalist construction, characterised by a monolithic or 'blocky' appearance and the large-scale use of poured concrete.

Given the proposed demolition of Argyle House would not take place until 2033 when the current lease expires there are bound to be more twists and turns in the future and while it would simply be replaced by flats and shops, that has to be better than what is there now.

News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice