Third Sector Fund is democracy in action - Ewan Aitken

The decision by Edinburgh Council’s planning committee to refuse the proposed “green” AI data centre was very welcome. AI is not just coming, it’s already here, and as a country we need to be ready for it, but not at any cost.

The suggestion that infrastructure with that level of power and water demand did not need an environmental assessment was disrespectful of the democratic process. The unanimous vote by councillors to reject, upheld the democratic process. Scotland needs AI infrastructure, but only with the transparency and clarity of impact.

Ewan Aitken, CEO Cyreniansplaceholder image
Ewan Aitken, CEO Cyrenians

The City Council’s proposal of a new £4.6 million Third Sector Support Fund is another good example of democracy in action. It grew from the loss of funding for a significant number of local community organisations (including Cyrenians) who are the lifeblood of the communities which are the bedrock of our city.

The councillors and their officers, to their credit, listened when we told them the loss of funding was not just about money, it was about how people flourish.

A successful city is built on strong communities which are nurtured by sustainable community groups where people build strong relationships which enhance their feeling of belonging, being able to influence their community and get access the help they need from people they know.

Having listened, the officers and councillors acted, creating both a short-term fund for organisations at risk, but also creating this new multiyear fund which I hope will be accepted at the Council’s budget meeting in two weeks. And I hope it’s done with cross party consensus and not used for political point scoring.

Democracy is under threat both here in Britian and across the world. Simplistic populist answers created by “othering” minorities, compounded by a refusal to adhere to any idea of truth, is undermining the global political process.

Here at home, for the last 10 years we have had a series of chaotic governments with leaders who seem unable to lead. Even those with integrity seem to be unable to give us a vision and a plan to get there.

The uncertainty this creates is not just bad for the economy but bad for democracy as it undermines trust in the decision makers and their decisions.

Local democracy is not perfect. There are city council decisions which feel like the opposite of the ones above. But at least they all, even the ones we might not like, were taken in a process which is close to those impacted by the outcomes.

My own experience of being a councillor was that people didn’t want to take decisions themselves, they wanted to know why a decision was taken, who took it, why they were the ones taking it and who they listened to when taking it.

Even when they disagreed with the outcome, if they knew those things, they were more likely to accept the decision. Not always, some people will always think you are only listening to them if you agree with them!

But the more decisions taken in places close to those most affected, the healthier our democracy will feel. More devolution to local councils and communities is the best way of creating a healthier democracy.

We may be scunnered with our democratic institutions, but if we imagine a world without them we realise why they are worth fight for.

News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice