Time will tell if this album will sink or swim
I was asked this week for the new album by Edinburgh band Swim School, and was fairly convinced it was not out yet as I didn’t remember seeing any pre-sell information from a distributor.
With the new shop looming I have been exceptionally busy so thought I had better check in case I had missed the relevant email. Sure enough an initial check showed the album was out this week but also a comprehensive search could find no attempt to sell it to me.


The label releasing the self-titled album turned out to be LAB Records who via a deal with Warner Music Group’s ADA is unsurprisingly distributed by Warner Music. ADA is the independent distribution and label services arm of Warner Music Group formed to break new artists and support more established artists.
The good news was I could now access the Warner website and check on the release and its stock. It transpired there were five different vinyl versions, a compact disc and a cassette with the drawback being there was no stock showing for any version. However it was clear the album was out so I contacted the Warners rep to see what the story was.
I have to admit I was surprised by the answer. It turned out the label manufactured the album themselves and shipped them direct to shops. They targeted towns where there was some activity and Assai as who were doing a signed obi edition.
Shops in Newcastle, Liverpool, Bury and Kingston had activity and signings as well as there being events in Edinburgh Dundee and Glasgow so some shops in these places received stock but no stock was sent to Atton the Warners warehouse in France that serves all of Europe including the UK.
I was also told that only once these events were over would the label send any remaining stock to the warehouse in France.
In all my years I’ve never come across such a bizarre strategy to sell an album. Don’t get me wrong with regards to chart positions the sales needed are so low for the Scottish chart that the album may well appear to have done well but these days chart positions are very much a case of smoke and mirrors.
Similarly concentrating on just a few record shops can easily produce a good chart placing in the record store chart but all this only works in week one and after that an album will quickly fall down if not completely out the charts.
At the same time why would a shop stock an album it was not allowed to have at the time of release? There are an awful lot of releases each week so few if any shops will see any reason to support this album when stock finally does appear.
It is a shame but this is by no means an isolated incident and while the strategy for this album is highly unusual there have been many cases in recent years of artists and labels shooting themselves in the foot by ignoring shops who would be supportive and putting all their eggs in one basket with a shop that will the next week be claiming another artist is their favourite.
Time will tell if this unusual strategy will see the album sink or swim.