Tram extension proving divisive and may be academic in the end - Steve Cardownie
One of the most talked about issues in Edinburgh politics just now is the proposed new north-south tramline.
Planned to run from Granton to Edinburgh Royal Infirmary and the BioQuarter at an estimated cost of £2.9 billion, it has been mired in controversy and its future has been brought into question as the results of the recent City Council consultation exercise have been made public. So, is it likely go ahead and, if so, what route is it likely to follow?


Transport Convener, Councillor Stephen Jenkinson, has already wasted no time in labelling the results as “fairly inconclusive.” He might have done so because, predictably, the outcome did not favour his preferred route -which is along the “Roseburn Path.”
Last year I wrote that “one thing that the City of Edinburgh Council could do to improve it’s relationship with the public is to treat them seriously when assessing the outcome of consultation exercises” as public confidence in the Council’s pledge to be a “listening” Council seemed to be at a low ebb at that time.
So, were the results of this most recent consultation exercise “fairly inconclusive” as Councillor Jenkinson claimed or was his statement no more than a weak attempt to muddy the waters?
For instance, when it came down to the proposal to run the line along the Roseburn Path, 68% of respondents expressed opposition, leaving only 32% in favour of Councillor Jenkinson’s preference.
I say “his” preference because as I pointed out in this paper, the Councillor had previously written a piece for The Herald newspaper in which he said that “the undeniable facts” of going across the Dean Bridge “are that it is calculated to cost hundreds of millions more than the Roseburn Path and ultimately carry fewer passengers,” thereby clearly expressing his support for the Roseburn Path route.
However, the Dean Bridge proposal hardly faired any better in the consultation exercise with 44% of responses against and only 32% in favour.
So, nether of the two proposed routes attracted a majority in favour, fairly awkward maybe, but fairly inconclusive-I think not!
Now, Councillor Jenkinson is obviously wedded to the idea that another tram line is necessary for the future of public transport in Edinburgh, after all, he has described the proposed North-South line as “one of the most ambitious and forward-thinking transport schemes in the country.” He is therefore unlikely to let the views of 11,425 people out of a city population of more than half-a- million divert him from this path (pun intended.)
The obvious question is where the money is going to come from to build this new tramline, but so far no one has provided any answers. The Scottish Government has said that it is a local project and so will not devote any money to it and the City Council has said that Edinburgh Council Taxpayers would not have to stump up either, so it all seems rather a bit academic at the moment.
However, the primary purpose of a consultation exercise is to gather feedback and advice to help inform and improve final decision making but
one unfortunate recurrent theme here is, if a Council consultation exercise does not come up with the desired result, there will be some local politicians who seem to be prepared to ignore it or undermine it.
