Transport needs more answers than walking and cycling - Iain Whyte
With the Princes Street closure set to be in place for at least the next three to four weeks it still seems to be all that people are talking about. No wonder when it is causing daily bus chaos and the curtailment of the tram line is hitting businesses hard in Leith.
Set this alongside the £9.3m loss that trams made in a full operating year, even with record passenger numbers, and you start to wonder what the final cost will be to the council budget in addition to the city in general.


To put that in context the trams lost two per cent of your Council Tax last year. But this only covers the debt for the Newhaven section, which was supposed to pay for itself. The debt for the first build to St Andrew Square costs you even more and is hidden within the council’s core finances.
Those losses must be building further with the inability to run a full service and Lothian Buses passenger numbers and costs will be hit too by the disruption they are facing. Dividend payment this year?
Much of this goes back to the way the council fails to plan for things. Tram bosses told the council they needed overnight “stabling” for tram vehicles at Newhaven at limited extra cost.
Unfortunately, this proved too difficult for the council. It would have allowed resilience in the current situation but more importantly would mean a much later last tram service to the most densely populated and youthful area of Scotland in normal times.
Comments in the Evening News this week from the sparring council leader and transport convener – they have a very different approach to fire damaged historic buildings – seem to berate me for challenging their plans for George Street pedestrianisation and for more trams.
But they can’t answer basic questions about the future running costs of their planned tram extensions or account for public transport resilience when their City Mobility Plan would close most routes in the city centre and force buses to be “to, not through”.
The current evidence suggests both issues are a problem. Their answer? We should all walk and cycle everywhere instead.
Maybe that will work for middle-class Londoners here for the Fringe and staying in the city centre. It’s not going to cut it for those who live and work here and travel in and through the city centre daily.