We should not allow racist thugs to besmirch our good reputation - Steve Cardownie
I was going to sarcastically write that I hope the morons who attacked the young female Chinese tourist in Princes Street Gardens last Friday are proud of themselves but on reflection, I think, sadly, that they probably are.
The University of Southampton student was visiting Edinburgh for the first time when she was punched in the face by one of the girls in the teenage group of five thugs that surrounded them as she was trying to protect her sister.


This treatment was meted out to her for simply being Chinese. After she posted news of the assault on Instagram other incidents were reported online of verbal and physical abuse on Princes Street and North Bridge. This prompted the City of Edinburgh Council leader, Jane Meagher to state that she was extremely disappointed to read of recent reports of attacks on Chinese and Asian people in the city.
The council leader was anxious to point out that Edinburgh was “a proud, welcoming and diverse city” and that she was saddened to hear of people feeling frightened to venture outside because of the incidence of racist attacks.
For the record, Edinburgh is, by and large, a safe city, despite the actions of some idiotic bampots who have nothing better to do than carry out physical attacks on people for no better reason than they have a different ethnic background to them.
Edinburgh is regularly ranked among the top three safest cities in Britain and street crime tends to be confined to petty theft, pick-pocketing and low-level antisocial behaviour, rather than serious violence.
At this time of year, when the city is host to hundreds of thousands of tourists, pickpocketing is the most common problem that visitors encounter, which is fairly typical of any major European tourist city.
Indeed, I encountered just such an incident when two pickpockets in Barcelona attempted to rob the former Lord Provost, George Grubb, until I intervened and offered them advice (mostly connected with sex and travel) in strong colloqial Leith terms, which they duly took, after lobbing a full can of Fanta in my direction. Shaken, but undeterred, George did not allow that incident to affect him and went on to thoroughly enjoy the rest of his visit.
According to the world’s largest crowd-sourced online data base, Numbeo’s, survey data puts confidence in walking alone at night in Edinburgh at 62 out of 100 rising to 83 during daylight hours, which is solidly positive.
Women’s safety surveys tell a similar story of positive statistics, with reported experiences of violence among women sitting around 12 per cent ,which is notably lower than many other UK cities.
Racist attacks are particularly abhorrent and we cannot afford to be complacent. While the city’s overall crime statistics compare favourably with other major cities the incidences of hate crime are on the increase.
The most recent figures from 2024/25 indicate that Edinburgh recorded 25 hate crimes per 10,000 population, the second-highest rate in Scotland after Glasgow’s 32 per 10,000.
Nationally 62 per cent of hate crimes had a race aggravator, 24 per cent sexual orientation, 12 per cent disability, 7 [er cent religion and 2 per cent transgender identity, all indicating that there is still work to be done.
We should not allow the divisive, callous actions of a mindless minority to besmirch our reputation as a welcoming host city!
