Why not just make the whole city a Firework Control Zone? - Steve Cardownie

A major City of Edinburgh Council consultation exercise’s opening statement says that “We’d like to hear from communities about areas being considered for Firework Control Zones (FCZ) this November. Your feedback will contribute to the decision-making process.”

The consultation period ends on August 5, so just a couple of weeks to go to complete the online survey.

A sign designating a firework control zone in Edinburghplaceholder image
A sign designating a firework control zone in Edinburgh

FCZs are for private spaces such as gardens or land managed by a community centre management committee, which limit the use of fireworks on that land for a specific period of time and the council points out that firework displays on public spaces are covered by different legislation.

Communities were able to apply for areas to be considered earlier this year, and these have been assessed and evaluated by the council, fire and police services.

The areas under consideration are Corstorphine, Gracemount/ The Murrays, Liberton/The Grange, Lochend, Longstone, Moredun, Sighthill/ Broomhouse, Stenhouse/Gaskell Street, Wester Hailes, and West Pilton.

If approved, these districts will join with those where such zones are already in place, namely Balerno, Calton Hill, Niddrie and Seafield.

The council promotes the policy of extending the areas to be covered as they “Can help reduce noise, stress, littering and antisocial behaviour caused by fireworks. They can be considered for misuse of fireworks/injuries, impact on vulnerable groups, environmental protection and animal welfare.”

According to the council’s website, it only considered requests for the implementation of an FCZ if it was made by a ‘community’, which it defines as “any group of people who feel they have something in common. In many cases they may live in the same area. Examples of communities are community councils, resident groups and stakeholders within the local community.”

In an FCZ it is against the law to set off fireworks anywhere, including on private property except for category 1 fireworks (sparklers, crackers, party poppers.) It is also illegal to set off fireworks that will enter an FCZ, although the council helpfully states that “Organised public firework displays are allowed, so people can enjoy fireworks safely.”

There is no doubt that the introduction of FCZs in Edinburgh has had a significant impact on the residents of areas where serious incidents of antisocial behaviour was prevalent in November.

In 2024 reports highlighted significant disturbances, including youths lobbing fireworks, bricks and bottles leading to injuries and property damage. The attacks on the police and firefighters who attended were particularly reprehensible and were rightly condemned by community leaders and residents alike.

Last year, anticipating potential disorder, the police seized over a tonne of fireworks bound for the city, and although some minor antisocial behaviour involving fireworks was reported the situation was less severe compared to previous years, so there is evidence that FCZs are producing the desired effect.

Local Authorities throughout Scotland are either considering the use of FCZs or currently deploy their use during November, so Edinburgh is not alone in experiencing the antisocial behaviour associated with firework use.

The council is to be commended for seeking to extend their use but given that such large parts of the city are to be designated FCZs why not go the whole hog and cover the whole city?

This would avoid any confusion about where an FCZ begins and ends and would also bring peace of mind to residents in areas that have not been considered.

Related topics:
News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice