FMQs: Nicola Sturgeon under fire after OAP's 13 hour trolley ordeal

Nicola Sturgeon apologised for the ordeal an elderly patient suffered. Picture: ScotsmanNicola Sturgeon apologised for the ordeal an elderly patient suffered. Picture: Scotsman
Nicola Sturgeon apologised for the ordeal an elderly patient suffered. Picture: Scotsman
An 80-year-old man waited more than three hours for an ambulance and then spent 13 hours stranded on a hospital trolley waiting for treatment, it has emerged.

Tom Wilson’s case was highlighted by Labour at First Minister’s Questions and led to Nicola Sturgeon apologising for the ordeal the elderly patient suffered.

Read More
Nigel Farage backs second Brexit referendum to “kill off” debate

Mr Wilson was found lying in a pool of blood after falling in his bathroom on the evening of New Year’s Day.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

An emergency call was made to the ambulance service. According to the pensioner’s family, it took three hours 17 minutes for the ambulance to arrive while Mr Wilson continued to bleed and drifted in and out of consciousness.

Despite Edinburgh Royal Infirmary (ERI) being just 14 minutes from Mr Wilson’s home in Newtongrange, the ambulance which finally arrived came from Kelso in the Borders.

The patient was taken to ERI where he was forced to spend 13 hours on a trolley in A and E before being admitted to a general ward.

Mr Wilson’s son Michael has emailed a letter to Health Secretary Shona Robison saying his father was treated “like an old cow waiting to die”.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

He also claimed his father could have died had his injuries been more serious. The letter described how he rushed from his home in Niddrie to be with his father after his mother rang him. His father appeared very confused and he managed to lift him out of the pool of blood into his bedroom during their long wait for help.

The letter added: “I am sure you will not even answer my email but I want to go to the papers and news and try to get this out as I am so fed-up of the lies and you saying the NHS is fine. I am lucky it was just the flu and cuts and bruises as if it was anything else he could have died waiting that long on an ambulance. “

More extracts from the letter, obtained by Labour, were read out by the party’s Scottish leader Richard Leonard as the Scottish Government’s stewardship of the NHS came under fire at First Minister’s Questions.

Quoting Mr Wilson’s son, Mr Leonard said: “I am sure you will say it has got nothing to do with you or the SNP and blame Westminster. I’ve seen on the news your answer is that we are doing better than England. Is this a joke?”

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

Mr Leonard then added: “First Minister, you have been found out by the people of Scotland. The doctors, the nurses, the ambulance crews, the patients and their families want to know what you are going to do to fix this mess. This mess you have created in our NHS.”

Mr Leonard said Mr Wilson was discharged after four days despite a nurse telling him he should stay in for longer, but his bed was needed.

Ms Sturgeon responded by apologising. She said: “What I say to Mr Wilson is very simple. I say sorry to Mr Wilson if that was his experience of the health service.

“I said earlier this week, the Health Secretary said in the chamber, that we apologise unreservedly - not just at winter but at any time of the year - to any patient who waits longer than they should do for hospital treatment or doesn’t get the standard of treatment they have a right to expect and I do that again unequivocally today. The Health Secretary will be more than happy to look into the specifics of Mr Wilson’s case if Mr Leonard wants to pass them to us.”