'Release the audio now': Back the Evening News demand over 'disgusting' VAR call which damaged Hearts' title hopes

Back our call for the VAR audio from Motherwell v Celtic to be released

The Scottish football landscape has been dominated today by the controversial decision to award Celtic a stoppage-time penalty in their match against Motherwell.

It is far from conclusive that the Motherwell player handled the ball and the call from the officials has left many within Scotland and beyond questioning how such a major decision was made.

There have been refereeing inconsistencies throughout the past two rounds of fixtures in the Premiership - and arguably throughout the whole season - that have had a major impact on one of the most thrilling title races in decades.

Hearts' title hopes were damaged on Wednesday night after a penalty was awarded to Celtic.placeholder image
Hearts' title hopes were damaged on Wednesday night after a penalty was awarded to Celtic. | SNS Group

The decision on Wednesday night didn't directly come against Hearts - but it certainly affects them. Rather than going three points clear with a superior goal difference going into Saturday's title decider against Celtic, the gap is now one point.

It hurts supporters even more when Hearts were denied a penalty against Motherwell on Saturday, when the referee was called upon by VAR to review the incident.

It has since come to light that the SFA agree Hearts ought to have been given the penalty, rather than it be waved away.

We believe the fairest thing to do would be for the authorities to release the audio from Motherwell v Celtic of referee John Beaton speaking to the VAR Andrew Dallas as to how the decision came about.

Referees have a tough job, and it would help everyone to have transparency as to how such a big call, that is now hogging the limelight, was made.

Agree with us? Sign our e-form and show that fans want an explanation for such a huge moment in Scottish football history. You will need to give an email address to sign the form but we will not be storing your details or contact you.

News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice