Row over removal of two members from Edinburgh health and social care body 'for voting against cuts'

Unions have accused NHS Lothian of removing two of its members from the body in charge of Edinburgh's health and social care because they voted against cuts to third sector organisations.

Former SNP councillor George Gordon and data expert Peter Knight were just reappointed to the Edinburgh Integration Joint Board earlier this year, but are now being replaced.

And in a letter to NHS Lothian chair Professor John Connaghan, Edinburgh Trade Union Council voiced its concern about their removal.

Peter Knight (left) and George Gordon have both been removed from the Edinburgh Integration Joint Boardplaceholder image
Peter Knight (left) and George Gordon have both been removed from the Edinburgh Integration Joint Board | collage

The letter said: "We believe [their removal] to to be unethical, unprofessional and an unprecedented attack on the democratic accountability we and the public have a right to expect.

"We believe the two members were removed because, at previous EIJB meetings, they voted against cuts to community and third sector bodies in Edinburgh.”

The letter, signed by Edinburgh TUC secretary Des Loughney, pointed out that IJB members are officially required to listen to and take into account public representations, in addition to assessing other evidence, in their decision making.

He said: "They had clearly taken account of the representations made by deputations from community groups, third sector organisations and trade unions and agreed that the proposed cuts would damage the health and social care of Edinburgh’s citizens.

"In their view the proposed cuts would have the greatest impact on lower income people, the elderly, the disabled and people with mental health conditions.

"They had argued that the cuts would in the long run be more expensive than the status quo because they would later impact on hospital admissions, GP practices and health and social services more generally. It has been evident that they saw the proposed cuts as a false economy.

"We believe that the two members were professionally entitled, in accordance with EIJB governance regulations to vote the way they did."

Green councillor Ross McKenzie raised the issue at Tuesday’s meeting of the EIJB.

He said: "Myself and some others were contacted by the trades council, who pointed out that the minutes of the IJB of May 13 show you noted the reappointment of Peter Knight for a further three years and the reappointment of George Gordon until the end of December 2026. Is there anyone here who can explain what changed between May and now?”

EIJB Katharina Kasper said: “This is a decision for the chair of NHS Lothian, John Connaghan. It is just the nature of an IJB - members can change. Before we go down this route of conspiracy theories, this is up to John Connaghan. If anything has been reported around the removal, I can absolutely refute that."

NHS Lothian said it routinely reviewed and rotated non-executive responsibilities in order to maintain objectivity, achieve balance in skills, experience and gender where possible, and bring fresh perspectives.

A spokeswoman said: “Recommendations on appointments are never influenced by individual actions, prior proceedings, or voting records. NHS Lothian fully supports the role of its nominated voting members on the IJBs, including their responsibility to exercise objectivity, independent judgment, and constructive challenge.”

Related topics:
News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice