Scottish Government mansion tax on homes over £1 million looks like 'tax on Edinburgh' says MSP

The Scottish Government's so-called mansion tax on homes worth over £1 million looks like a "tax on Edinburgh", according to one city MSP.

Labour's Daniel Johnson, MSP for Edinburgh Southern, said most of the properties hit by the new tax will be in or around the Capital.

And he has written to Finance Secretary Shona Robison with a series of questions to try and get clarity on exactly how it will work.

Edinburgh Southern Labour MSP Daniel Johnsonplaceholder image
Edinburgh Southern Labour MSP Daniel Johnson

Ms Robison announced in her Budget last week that two new council bands will be introduced on homes for the most expensive properties in Scotland, those worth more than £1 million on an up-to-date valuation.

The new bands are due to come into effect by April 2028. Ms Robison described the move as "a measure that will bring greater fairness as well as increased revenues to councils".

But Mr Johnson said: “We already know that Edinburgh City Council receives the lowest funding per head of any local authority in Scotland and now the SNP want to levy a council tax hike which will impact Edinburgh more than any other part of the country, without any guarantees local services will benefit.

“The Scottish Government must clarify whether money raised from this tax will go to Edinburgh Council or whether this is simply a tax on Edinburgh.”

In his letter to the Finance Secretary he notes her plan to “re-evaluate all properties in council tax bands G and H” and to “create an additional levy on properties which exceed £1,000,000 in valuation”.

But he points out: “Last year over half of all properties that sold in bands G and H were in Edinburgh.”

And he asks Ms Robison for more detail of what she is proposing and Edinburgh’s position:

- When will the re-evaluation process take place and when will the additional levy be introduced?

- What methodology will be used to re-evaluate properties?

- What will the additional levy/levies be charged at?

- More generally, can you set out the current per capita funding provided to Edinburgh through the general grant?

- Similarly, can you set out the per capita funding for health, police and fire services to Edinburgh?

- Will the additional sums raised by the levy be retained by the city of Edinburgh council or will they go to the Scottish Government?

Mr Johnson concluded his letter: “In recent years, Edinburgh has received the lowest level of funding per capita of any local authority in Scotland.

“My concern is both that this levy will disproportionately impact Edinburgh residents and will not result in an increase in council revenue.

“People pay council tax on the basis that their taxes pay for local services. If the funds raised simply go into the Scottish Government budget it is hard to avoid the conclusion that this will be a tax on Edinburgh.”

Ms Robison said: “The introduction of two new high value council tax bands will provide a targeted approach to improve fairness at the top end of the system, while generating a recurring source of increased revenue for local authorities.

“This is in contrast to proposals from the UK Government for England where their levy will return the revenue to the central Treasury.

“The Scottish Government will meet the cost of the targeted revaluation, ensuring that local government will benefit directly from the additional revenue raised.”

And on Edinburgh’s funding she said: “The record £15.7 billion settlement for local authorities is the result of meaningful budget engagement with Cosla and councils.

“We recognise the financial challenges that local authorities face, which is why we have provided a Budget which builds on the Verity House Agreement and Fiscal Framework agreement.”

News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice