Senior Edinburgh Labour figures 'may not vote for party on the list' amid concerns over top candidate

Senior Labour figures in Edinburgh have told friends they may not cast their list vote for the party because they do not want to see the number one candidate become an MSP.

Businessman Irshad Ahmad has been at the centre of controversy ever since the results of the ranking process - where party members vote on the order of candidates for the regional list - were announced last month.

To widespread surprise within the party, Mr Ahmad - who has previously been a member of the SNP and then Alba - emerged in top place on the Edinburgh and Lothians East list, ahead of two sitting Labour MSPs, Daniel Johnson and Martin Whitfield.

There have been claims that Mr Ahmad is not well-known within the Labour party and that he recruited a large number of new members ahead of the internal ballot.

There has even been speculation that he could defect from Labour to the SNP once he is elected as an MSP.

Concerns were expressed about Mr Ahmad at last weekend's Labour party Scottish Executive Committee when it met to endorse all the list candidates across the country.

It is understood a vote had to be held and some people were not willing to endorse Mr Ahmad, but the list was ultimately approved as it stood.

In Edinburgh and Lothians East, the number one slot for Labour is seen as almost guaranteeing election to Holyrood.

But one party source said: "There are ex-MPs and councillors who have said they'll have to consider whether they can actually vote for Labour on the list. I think the party's got a real problem. People are really angry about it."

It is also understood a number of MSPs have spoken to Scottish Labour leader Anas Sarwar and his deputy Jackie Baillie to voice their concern.

Under Labour party rules, candidates can only stand on the list if they are also a constituency candidate. Mr Arshad is standing in Edinburgh North-Western after winning the selection, reportedly by 20 votes to 19.

There were concerns about similar issues in that contest too, but a party investigation found no irregularities.

Mr Ahmad has stood twice before for Holyrood. In 2016, he was the number four SNP candidate for the Lothians list, but was not elected. And in 2021, he stood for Alba on the Lothians list - again in fourth slot and again without success.

A Scottish Labour spokesperson said: “All selections are run in accordance with rules agreed by Scottish Labour’s executive committee.”

Related topics:
News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice