Trolleybus could have saved Granton economic transport link - Bruce Whitehead
“My brother, knows Karl Marx He met him eating mushrooms in the People’s Park He said: 'What do you think about my manifesto?' 'I like your manifesto! Let's put it to the test-o!” (The Sultans of Ping, “Where's Me Jumper?”)*
As we reported on Wednesday, “political jostling” was the polite term used by Granton Community Council, as it reacted to the misguided Edinburgh council vote to ditch Granton’s vital economic transport link.


GCC's chair Fred Marinello said politics played “too big a part” in the decision, and he’s right. Usually I'd trust elected council officials, if comprehensively briefed by expert public servants, to make well-informed decisions fulfilling manifesto promises.
But how often do they renege on popular shopping lists offered during election campaigns, or suddenly reveal un-announced, unpopular "hard decisions" once they're in power?
I argued transport officials should have comprehensively researched ALL transport options to extend the tram line. FutureTrams assured me that they'd done this. But they failed to examine trolleybus, which shares existing lines while needing only overhead power, and no track, to rapidly extend the reach of the clean public transport network. The objections to tram extension – Dean Bridge load and Roseburn Path concerns – are solved by trolleybus, a similar weight to E-buses currently using the bridge, and which can avoid Roseburn by using existing bus routes.
As Fred Marinello knew and councillors evidently forgot, nearly £2bn is being spent on 20 years’ worth of development which anticipated the tram extension, on housing and waterfront regeneration. It's a cop-out by ill-informed councillors who really don't know their brief.
It all gives democracy a bad name, leading to low voter turnout and trust. Pilton (where I lived as a toddler) and Granton's only hope is that the matter is re-visited by the new council administration after May 2027 Edinburgh council elections.
So here's a rallying call: Edinburgh voters need to challenge prospective councillors relentlessly over the next eight months, holding them to account and demanding robust manifesto pledges for the kind of city we all deserve.
Here's my Demands Manifesto:
- re-assess Granton's sustainable transport link using trolleybus
- re-open all police stations and catch antisocial drivers and offenders
- more affordable homes; end luxury student flats loophole
- stop pouring chemicals “very toxic to marine life with lasting effects” into the regenerating Forth oyster fishery at the Hawes Pier (vehicles sprayed sodium hypochlorite twice this week; look it up!)
- COLLECT bus lane and traffic fines to deter car use and free up bus and cycle lanes for healthy active travel
- £2 transport cap on all Edinburgh public transport with multimode tickets for train, tram, bus, hirebike and trolleybus (!)
- free music tuition to any school pupil who wants it, regardless of their ability
- free after school sports of choice to any child who needs it, regardless of their skill level
- freshly cooked healthy school meals...
Please send in your suggestions and let's hold our council candidates to account!