Trolleybuses are the answer, not trams - Bruce Whitehead

This week the trams expansion consultation ended with over 11,000 responses – one was mine.

A much more authoritative response was from my friend Lesley Hinds, who as transport convener rescued the 2014 reopening (trams were only temporarily removed in 1956).

Iveco Crealis Neo 18 articulated trolleybus of Tper public transportation company in Bolognaplaceholder image
Iveco Crealis Neo 18 articulated trolleybus of Tper public transportation company in Bologna

Lesley argued for the Roseburn Path route to be adopted in favour of the Dean Bridge, saving £300m and years more delay.

However, I respectfully disagree with my former Labour colleague. Some readers may be wearily familiar with my banging on about the alternatives to tram, but first, let's remember why a transport rethink was necessary.

Edinburgh has some of the worst traffic congestion in Scotland. This causes jams, spewing toxic emissions despite a modest increase in hybrids and EVs. CO2 damages the planet's lungs, increasing storms and flooding, while NOx atmospheric pollution damages children's lungs.

Planners looked for ways to reduce these hazards with cleaner public transport and the winning formula was heavy trams able to shift hundreds of Edinburghers around quicker than cars and buses.

Buses fought back, with hybrid engines that switch off at rest; driver complaints persuaded managers to over-ride the cutoffs, and the emissions grew again. Bad move, buses!

But the planners failed to foresee the massive delays caused by re-routing of ancient drains, gas mains, power lines and telecommunications to accommodate heavy trams. Since then, an older version of trams – which was also discontinued in the 50s – has been re-born.

They're basically trams with rubber tyres, just as large and powerful but with similar electric motors, meaning the power can be generated elsewhere, reducing emissions and with a majority of power now from renewables, much cleaner.

They can steer, so they don't block other traffic, but best of all they can share the overhead tram power lines. And, needing no track, they can use existing roads, serving all neighbourhoods.

Trolleybuses are the answer, not trams. Look at the photo. Nice isn't it? Edinburgh transport chiefs please take note!

News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice