Giant poster appears in city centre condemning Melville Monument

A giant billboard poster which condemns the controversial Melville Monument, which has come under attack given its links to slavery, has appeared outside a city centre church.
The billboard has appeared outside St John's on the corner of Lothian Road and Princes Street. PIC: Contributed.The billboard has appeared outside St John's on the corner of Lothian Road and Princes Street. PIC: Contributed.
The billboard has appeared outside St John's on the corner of Lothian Road and Princes Street. PIC: Contributed.

The artwork now hangs outside St John’s Church on the corner of Lothian Road and Princes Street.

The poster features a picture of the Melville Monument alongside the caption “Wish You Weren’t Here”.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

The space outside the church is often used to display campaigning pieces of artwork.

The picture carries a photograph of the Melville Monument, which has come under attack given its links to the slave trade, and features the words "Wish You Weren't Here".The picture carries a photograph of the Melville Monument, which has come under attack given its links to the slave trade, and features the words "Wish You Weren't Here".
The picture carries a photograph of the Melville Monument, which has come under attack given its links to the slave trade, and features the words "Wish You Weren't Here".

The Melville Monument, which stands in nearby St Andrew Square, has become a focal point for recent Black Lives Matter protests.

It has been vandalised by anti-racism campaigners in light of the police killing of George Lloyd in Minneapolis.

Some have called for the statue to be removed.

The monument was built to honour Henry Dundas, 1st Viscount Melville, a former advocate and influential politician.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

As Home Secretary, he frustrated efforts to end the slave trade after William Wilberforce MP introduced his abolition bill to parliament in 1792.

Campaigners say this aspect of Dundas’ record must be illuminated alongside the imposing memorial in his name.

Read More
Plaque to be added to Melville Monument to outline link to slave trade

Dundas proposed support for Wilberforce’s bill but put forward an amendment that the abolition of slave trading would occur ‘gradually’.

Done to appease the powerful pro-slavery lobby, it is estimated that the 15-year delay to abolition created by the amendment led to a further 630,000 Africans being forced into a life of chattel slavery.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

Prime Minister William Pitt later said that gradual abolition was an “enormous evil”.

Following a long campaign, a plaque is due to be placed at the monument to outline Dundas’ support for gradual abolition.

This weekend, a descendant of Henry Dundas claimed his forefather should actually be praised for his role in ending slavery.

Bobby Dundas, the 10th Viscount Melville, claied that his seven-time great-grandfather played a key role in bringing the slave trade to an end.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

The Viscount said: “Henry Dundas was an abolitionist. He was for the abolition of the slave trade. That has been written about by countless people. But you have to understand in the current climate, what was UK politics and the British Empire.

“There was one failed attempt to get it through Parliament and the realistic and pragmatic approach that Dundas took was the only way - which many historians have written about - to make sure that the vision and final goal was achieved.’

Related topics: