The fast food restaurant on London Road will now have to shut its doors at 2am on Fridays and Saturdays and 1am the rest of the week after councillors refused to approve a 24-hour application, following a trial period.
In June 2018, the council’s licensing sub-committee agreed to allow the premises to operate until 5am on a trial basis.
Following the trial, the company came back to the committee to ask for the late licence to continue – but police raised objections to the application and the committee voted to reject the extension.
Love Island 2022: When is the Love Island reunion on TV? Date, time and how to watch
12 bizarre facts you wouldn’t believe are true about Edinburgh
Edinburgh Festival Fringe 2022: Here are 10 children's shows you can already book tickets for - including the Amazing Bubble Man and Basil Brush
Edinburgh's Tynecastle Stadium: Here are 20 pictures from the 1950s and 1960s showing how much the Hearts ground has changed
Edinburgh's Grassmarket: 17 pictures from the 1950s and 1960s show how the historic street has changed
In a letter to the committee, Police Scotland said the extended hours has “resulted in further disturbance and nuisance to residents” and has “increased demand for police resources”. Officers praised measures introduced by management since April 2017 such as employing security staff that have “greatly reduced the number of calls” to police.
But officers highlighted incidents of crime and disorder that occurred during the trial. On July 16, 2018 a member of the public called the police after he was assaulted in the restaurant at around 3.45am. Sergeant John Young told councillors that police “had no call from the premises whatsoever”.
A 29-year-old man was waiting for his food order when he was approached by another man who punched him in the head “for a sustained period” before hitting them over the head with a glass bottle. No arrests have been made and inquiries are ongoing.
Sergeant Young added: “One of our top priorities within Edinburgh is to deter antisocial behaviour and associated offences, while at the same time keeping the public safe when visiting any premises subject to licensing conditions.”
Jonathan Guy, representing McDonald’s, told councillors it hadn’t been reported to police by staff due to “timing” and said that the restaurant is “extremely well run” .
He added: “Over a six-month period, there have been five incidents. There have been no concerns over the number of incidents in the increased hours trial. There have been an additional 50,000 customers, yet there has been no increase of antisocial incidents at the restaurant.”
Licensing convener, Cllr Catherine Fullerton, called for an extension to the late hours licence to be approved.
She said: “I’m of the view that we did ask them that there’s no further incidents in extending the hours and there has not been any increase in that period.”
But councillors voted against renewing the late hours licence.
Cllr Stephanie Smith said: “The fact that an assault occurred inside the restaurant and the police were not notified by the restaurant themselves is very concerning.”
A McDonald’s spokesperson said: “We are disappointed with this decision and are reviewing our options in moving forward.”