Dispatch Trophy delivers delight, dreams and drama on opening day at Braids
Golf correspondent Martin Dempster rounds up the first-day action in the historic team tournament
Dad’s Army pulling off an “unexpected” win, two teenagers shining, a decorated team bowing out early and the last match going to the 20th hole.


As always, it was an exciting opening day in the 126th Edinburgh Evening News Dispatch Trophy at the Braids, where the head greenkeeper had more than one reason to have a smile on his face.
Edinburgh Western dubbed themselves Dad’s Army before teeing off in a second-round clash with Colinton Mains, a club within Swanston.


That’s because Andrew Rennie is 63, David Wilson is 60, Danny Cameron is 61 and Matt Davidson is the youngster of the Braids club’s quartet at 57.
According to playing partner Rennie, Davidson “nearly broke the pin with a chip” but the pair combined to finish three up at the front against Ross Fergus and Calum McKinnon.
With Wilson and Cameron ending up all square at the back in their match with Scott Fergus and Struan Renwick, Edinburgh Western progressed to the last 16 with a 3&2.
“It was unexpected,” declared Rennie, a stalwart of the Edinburgh Leisure-run event, while Davidson said they were “making up the numbers in some ways due to better players being unavailable”.
As the latest edition of the historic tournament got underway in favourable conditions, it was also a day to cherish for 14-year-old Harry Mody and 15-year-old Freddie Stevenson.


Mody, hailed as Swanston’s “shining light at the moment”, joined forces with Paul Stewart, Nick Harrison and Mark Evans to chalk up a 3&2 win over MCBA.
Stevenson, meanwhile, teamed up with Scott Knowles to help Harrison B, with Robbie Groom and Mark Anderson also doing their bit, pull off one of the shocks of the day with a 2&1 victory over six-time winners Silverknowes.
“Freddie is playing in the event for the first time and there was a 49-year age gap out there,” said Knowles, a former Scottish Order of Merit winner who runs the Stephen Gallacher Foundation these days. “He was solid and was sensible as well because he wasn’t scared to hit irons off tees.”
Turnhouse, with former Lothians champion Steven Armstrong chasing the one big prize in Lothians golf missing from his CV, won two games to progress to the third round, as did Heriot’s FP.
It wasn’t looking as though that would be the case as Mortonhall front couple Harry Carruthers and Jamie Gullen won the first extra hole in the third round and David Greig had driven the green in the back match.


But, in a dramatic turnaround, Kenneth Rocke raced Mortonhall’s eagle putt past the hole and Heriot’s nicked it as Steven Sinclair rolled in a birdie putt before Sinclair and Scott Dickson then won the 20th with a par.
“It was one of those classic Dispatch Trophy moments,” observed Dickson after joining Heriot’s Quad in the last 16 after Innes Christie, Euan Gordon, John Liddel and Stewart Heggie also scraped through in extra time.
Defending champions Hailes are through to Tuesday night’s action as well, as are an Edinburgh Leisure team that contains Scott Higgins, who, in his role as head greenkeeper, was out at the crack of dawn preparing the course before helping his team beat Musselburgh Old at the 19th.
“It was strange playing against my own club and also one of my best mates in Paul Marshall,” said Musselburgh Old member Higgins. “But I love it up here and feel honoured to be head greenkeeper at the oldest course in the city.”
To his credit and the other members of the greenkeeping team, there was a chorus of praise for the condition of the course as the Braid Hills Golf Centre-sponsored event got off to another great start.
RESULTS
First round
Donuts@The 9th w/o Haddington
Murrayfield w/o Hailes B
Caermount (Iain Parrish and Martin Hopley 0; Graeme Lewington and Gary Henshaw 0); Turnhouse (Steven Armstrong and Eddie Jackson 6; Keith Watt and Blair Henry 2).
Turnhouse won 8&7
Hailes w/o Duddingston
Mortonhall (Harry Carruthers and Jamie Gullan 3; David Greig and Kenneth Rocke 4); Kilgour Wealth Management (David Graham and Fraser McCallum 0; Stuart Turner and Max Christie 0).
Mortonhall won 7&6
Caermount (Iain Parrish and Martin Hopley 0; Graeme Lewington and Gary Henshaw 0); Turnhouse (Steve Armstrong and Eddie Jackson 6; Keith Watt and Blair Henry 2).
Turnhouse won 8&7
Heriot’s FP (Ben Alexander and Elliot Innes 0; Steven Sinclair and Scott Dickson 3); Edinburgh Thistle (Ian Cropley and Donald Anderson 1; Barrie Anderson and David Greenshields 0).
Heriot’s FP won by two holes
Second round
Donuts@the9th (Alistair Dougal and John Nisbet 0; Fraser Jervis and Chris Birrell 0); Murrayfield (Cameron Whyte and Bobby Gibson 1; Stuart Thurlow and Harrison Shaw 7).
Murrayfield won 8&6
Turnhouse (Steven Armstrong and Eddie Jackson 0; Keith Watt and Blair Henry 4); Kilgour Property Management (Owen Melrose and Adam Heslop 0; David Downie and Gus Santana 0).
Turnhouse won 4&3
Dalmahoy Hotel & Country Club (Luke Wu and Richard Fyvie 0; Michael Jackson and Scott McClory 5); Harrison (Donny Munro and Elliot Munro 3; Briam Byars and Aidan Byars 0).
Dalmahoy Hotel & Country Club won 2&1
Riccarton B (Andy Laurence and David Smith 0; Jim Downie and Jack Downie 0); Kilspindie (Martin Hay and Grant Robertson 0; Rob Green and Derek Thomson 6).
Kilspindie won 6&5
Edinburgh Western (Matt Davidson and Andrew Rennie 3; David Wilson and Danny Cameron 0); Colinton Mains (Ross Fergus and Callum McKinnon 0; Scott Fergus and Struan Renwick 0).
Edinburgh Western won 3&2
Thistle 1870 (Ross Turner and Niall Moffat 6; Luke Robinson and Tom Olley 0); Silverknowes B (Jordan Irvine and Paul Heggie 0; Keith Tulloch and Steve Garrioch 0).
Thistle 1870 won 6&4
Harrison B (Scott Knowles and Freddie Stevenson 4; Robbie Groom and Mark Anderson 0); Silverknowes (Keith Reilly and Graeme Robertson 0; Chris Milligan and Connor McWatt 2).
Harrison B won 2&1
Riccarton A (Mark Riddell and Owen Brady 5; Jake Edgcombe and Fergus Lockhart 3); Clark Technical Consultancy (Mark Boggie and Johnny Watt 0; David Hunt and Ryan Telfer 0).
Riccarton A won 8&7
MCBA (Fraser Clark and Fergus Perks 0; Peter Cockburn and David Hutton 0); Swanston (Harry Mody and Paul Stewart 2; Nick Harrison and Mark Evans 1).
Swanston won 3&2
Merchants of Edinburgh (Kevin Girdler and Fraser Smith 0; Ross Hannah and Adam George 0); Carrickvale (Gregor Maiden and Ross Colquhoun 6; Paul Cunningham and Allyn Dick 4).
Carrickvale won 10&9
Edinburgh Leisure (Matthew Harper and Cameron Ledingham 0; Scott Higgins and Gary Reilly 3); Musselburgh Old Course (Ross Noon and Keiran Blyth 3; Paul Marshall and Ryan Henderson 0).
Edinburgh Leisure won at 19th
BBT w/o Bass Rock
Lochend (Graeme Markey and Jamie Crisp 0; Leon McNicol and Tommy Burnett 0); Stewart’s Melville FP (Scott Simpson and Drew McIntosh 1; Guy Dalziel and Stuart McLaren 7).
Stewart’s Melville FP won 8&6
Heriot’s Quad (Innes Christie and Euan Gordon 0; John Liddel and Stewart Heggie 4); Buckstone (David Liddle and Craig Taylor 4; Andrew Hogg and Paul Logan 0).
Heriot’s Quad won at 19th
Watsonians (Scott James and Richard Craig 3; Brian Tait and Graeme Johnston 0); Hailes (Steve McCulloch and Fraser Sutherland 0; Paul Page and Danny Crolla 6).
Hailes won 3&1
Mortonhall (Harry Carruthers and Jamie Gullan 0; David Greig and Kenneth Rocke 0); Heriot’s FP (Ben Alexander and Elliot Innes 0; Steven Sinclair and Scott Dickson 0).
Heriot’s FP won at 20th
