Adversity is only going to make this club so much stronger, insists Edinburgh City boss Michael McIndoe

Edinburgh City manager Michael McIndoe believes so much adversity in recent times will stand the club in good stead going forward.

Having finished rock bottom of League Two last month, the Citizens secured their survival overcoming Highland League champions Brora Rangers in the pyramid play-off.

Edinburgh City manager Michael McIndoe, left, and assistant Kirk Crichton. Picture: Tommy Leeplaceholder image
Edinburgh City manager Michael McIndoe, left, and assistant Kirk Crichton. Picture: Tommy Lee

Rewind the clock 10 months, though, and a sense of optimism was swiftly replaced with deep despair when the club was deducted 15 points for an insolvency event - a matter of days after the 2-1 defeat to Stirling in their league opener - and a punishment that so nearly cost them a place in Scottish football's fourth tier.

To rub salt into the wounds, the Meadowbank outfit will also begin the 2026/2027 campaign with a five-point deduction as a final sanction for their breach of SPFL rules.

And although City will once again be playing catch up on their rivals, McIndoe is confident he can assemble a squad that is capable of competing at the opposite end of the table this time round.

This isn't the first instance the club have been docked points for off-the-field matters. In January 2024, while plying their trade in League One, a six-point deduction was imposed for failure to pay players' wages. McIndoe had only taken over the reins from Alan Maybury fours months prior.

It's fair to say McIndoe, who carved out a playing career in England with Bristol City, Doncaster Rovers, and Coventry, has been dealt the rough end of the stick during his 32-month tenure.

"We always spend the first few weeks at the end of the campaign reflecting on what we've done well and what we can do better," McIndoe told the Evening News. "If we go back right to the start of last season, having lost our second league game, we then found ourselves 18 points behind. This was my first taste as a manager of being hit with such a big points deduction. We dealt with the six points the previous season, but this was huge.

"We had to plan. We wanted to try and get those points back as quickly as possible. That sounds basic, but we changed the formation to suit some of the players for the shorter term. I knew it would work in the short term but I wasn't convinced it would work longer term because I bring players to the football club to play a certain way.

"I knew we had to negate that, particularly in the first 10 games and it was crucial we got something back on the board to keep the momentum going with the current group.

"We couldn't play our usual risk-attacking football because if we lost two or three games on the bounce, we could have found ourselves 25 points behind. We took a little more of a direct route and it won us some games. But the key thing is even though we won a few, we were still bottom.

"Our captain Jason Jarvis then went for a hernia operation in December and that coincided with us losing games. We had also lost Tiwi Daramola for the season after just two games. Coming into the Christmas period, Lewis McArthur was injured for two months, some players lost form due to the amount of energy they'd put into the first 18 games or so, and we were still rock bottom of the table. It was a bitter pill to swallow.

"We then had an offer for our best player at the time, Robbie Mahon, who we sold to Airdrie, so when you start to piece it together and say why did we not win a lot of games in January and February? The answer is staring at you in the face. Quinn Mitchell was also out for six weeks with a broken toe. It was a really challenging time.

"We ended up having two teams this year because we had to challenge the players to a level of consistency that they couldn't keep up. Having to ask them to win every game is just beyond their capabilities. I could see that so we needed fresh blood in January, but we were bringing in 18-year-olds from Airdrie, and utilising our academy. We ended up with 62 appearances from our academy, which is quite incredible.

"But we kept the team up following great adversity again. There were five or six times we got on the tailcoats of Dumbarton, but every time we lost a game, the gap widened again. I've learned that 15 points isn't 15 points. It's 30. And I mean that in the context of you lose 15 points, but then you probably lose another 15 on momentum. If you dig a hole for five months and then the water comes back into that hole, it's quite demoralising."

McIndoe put pen to paper on a new three-year deal two days after guiding City to SPFL safety. However, that was only after receiving assurance from chairman John Dickson that any threat of further punishment for foul play is confined to the past. The 46-year-old has elected not to jet off for sunnier climes and is instead reshaping his squad ahead of the new season which gets underway with the visit of Premiership outfit Falkirk, in Premier Sports Cup Group G duty, on Saturday, July 11.

McIndoe has already recruited Shea Dowie, Robbie Leitch, Cammy McKinley, Josh Grigor, Chris McGinn, Jordan McGregor, and Lennon Walker, for what he believes will be a campaign to remember for all the right reasons.

"We've got to start with minus 5, I get it," he said. "I've been in the job about two-and-a-half seasons and, in that time, we've had 26 points deducted, two transfer embargoes, lost a whole squad one Christmas and, on top of that, we have the smallest budget with the smallest group of players. It's been extremely challenging, but in a good way. I've achieved things in football but keeping the club up has been the biggest of them all.

"I knew once we got our key players back, and gelled them with what we had, that it would take a very off-day on both legs to lose the play-off against Brora. We played Dumbarton the week before and we did exceptionally well to beat them 5-0, so we have the makings of a very good group, not to mention the players we've just added.

"I've been in the office and working. I've probably been the busiest manager in League Two with the signings we've made. I like to get my business done nice and early.

"I also think the board and the owners have learned a lot. Football is fast and fluid and there is very little room for error on and off the pitch. If you give me a level playing field, I reckon we can blow teams away.

"We had strong discussions. I've had assurances from the chairman and the board this will never happen again. What we need now is to bring everyone together and understand the objective, which is to take on every single club in Scottish football because it's not just about League Two, if you're going to be a underdog, whether it be a league or cup game, it's very unusual for us to be favourites.

"Inverness started with minus 5 and they still won the league. So I've told the players that and it will be a motivating factor. We finished club 42 last year. Every time we cross that white line we are the underdog.

"We've got some great signings so far but we'll still be working with a 17-man squad, probably seven down from everyone else, but I truly believe we will win the league next season."

He continued: "We're moving the dark clouds away from Edinburgh City Football Club. But also it's about loyalty. Let's be straight if we'd lost the play-off game, it would have been very difficult for me to stay because I would have had offers elsewhere. I've proved my loyalty to the football club, I want to move with the team through the divisions.

"If we're going to be the smallest club, we have to be the most organised. if something needs to be done on a Saturday, get it done the week before. That's what I've been drilling in to my staff and the board. The plan is to get this club up the divisions, it's as simple as that.

"I can see these changes being implemented. I'm also putting a lot of time into the academy because that is the future of our club."

News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice