The Hearts pundits have been out in force after a 2-1 Scottish Cup semi final loss vs Aberdeen.
Pape Habe Gueye put the Dons ahead before a Lawrence Shankland leveller. Michael Steinwender was sent off for the Jambos but Neil Critchley’s men matched or bettered Aberdeen in large elements of a game that spanned 120 minutes after extra time.
Cammy Devlin was controversially sent off for a second booking and Oday Dabbagh pounced to send Aberdeen into a final where they will meet Celtic or St Johnstone. Hearts’ season will end with bottom six fixtures in the Premiership and chances of European football next term are over.
Here are how 11 pundits saw the game unfold between Hearts and Aberdeen.

9. John Robertson (Sportsound)
"It is a lack of communication from Aberdeen. Shinnie is sucked into the middle with Wilson. His centre-halves have that under control and he makes a stupid challenge. Shankland drills it in. I'd rather Neil Critchley had kept Kabangu up there to stretch the Aberdeen defence. The first red, you couldn't really argue. The second, there's no intent from Devlin, he's just trying to hook the ball away and can't see the Aberdeen player." | SNS Group

10. Steve Conroy and Des Roache (Ref's View)
"Correct decision to send off Hearts defender in Scottish Cup Semi. DOGSO. Doesn’t need to be a “shoe in”, just a clear opportunity. Never a yellow card, Devlin’s first probably wasn’t a yellow either. Beaton got the red card right earlier in the game but got this spectacularly wrong." Photo: SNS Group

11. Alan Hutton (Premier Sports)
"It's a great goal by Hearts. If you give Shankland the room he will deliver and that is what he did. He had one thought. If you put him in the right areas of the pitch he will score." | Getty Images

