12 pundits predict Hibs vs Hearts as Edinburgh derby throws up five-goal thriller, a cracker and pitch chaos

Here’s how the pundits see Thursday’s Edinburgh derby panning out.

Hibs and Hearts are ready to do battle in the latest instalment of the Edinburgh derby.

Both head into their first Premiership clash of the season in Leith with good domestic form. They have six points from nine available and are both into next week’s Premier Sports Cup quarter-final line-up. They are now hoping to keep the feel good factor going and avoid momentum derailing against their biggest rival with this Edinburgh derby taking place in Leith.

Pundits have been out in force with their Edinburgh derby predictions, with some expecting chaos, others seeking goals, and star men being tipped to thrive. Here’s how 12 pundits see Hibs vs Hearts going in Thursday night’s Edinburgh derby.

Related topics:
News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice