Neil Critchley’s era at Hearts is over and now a period of soul searching is commencing at Tynecastle.
A 1-0 defeat to Dundee leaves the club eighth and five points off the relegation play off spot of 11th. Under Critchley’s tenure that lasted six months, Hearts exited the Conference League at the league phase stage with a draw vs Petrocub, did not win a derby and also missed two chances to finish in the top six.
They also lost a Scottish Cup semi final vs Aberdeen, albeit ending that game with nine men. A whole host of opponents were faced during Critchley’s reign and most of them have had a verdict on Hearts as a club, a team and even the head coach himself.
Here are 17 of the verdicts from over the Hearts tenure of Critchley.

5. Andrei Martin (Petrocub)
“We got a very good score and we are so proud of this. I wish your team good luck moving forward and I hope you get the results you want.” | SNS Group

6. Philippe Clement (Rangers)
"The team showed the right mentality as a group - the players who started, the players who came in - in going into the fight, which is what's necessary here (at Tynecastle). Also against a Hearts team that went full in for the victory with an offensive playing style, with a lot of attacking players with good quality. The team dug in and took (chances) at the right moments during the game.” | SNS Group

7. Tony Docherty (Dundee)
"I thought Hearts were unlucky against Aberdeen. Hearts have got very good players, a really strong squad of players. We need to make sure we’re ready for whatever team comes out." | SNS Group

8. Miron Muslic (Cercle Brugge)
"Very different, especially since head coach (Neil) Critchley took over. First of all very well coached, clear patterns, possession based. A lot of possession for a Scottish team to be fair, a lot of good things on the ball. They feel very comfortable with the ball. Kilmarnock was way more physical, way more direct, with long balls picking up the second. I think also this is in a repertoire of Hearts, but still with the capacity and the quality to build up, to prepare the attack, to progress the game from the defence to the midfield, looking then for Lawrence Shankland as a clear target player, a clear number nine." Photo: Dan Istitene

