Neil Critchley’s era at Hearts is over and now a period of soul searching is commencing at Tynecastle.
A 1-0 defeat to Dundee leaves the club eighth and five points off the relegation play off spot of 11th. Under Critchley’s tenure that lasted six months, Hearts exited the Conference League at the league phase stage with a draw vs Petrocub, did not win a derby and also missed two chances to finish in the top six.
They also lost a Scottish Cup semi final vs Aberdeen, albeit ending that game with nine men. A whole host of opponents were faced during Critchley’s reign and most of them have had a verdict on Hearts as a club, a team and even the head coach himself.
Here are 17 of the verdicts from over the Hearts tenure of Critchley.

13. Stuart Kettlewell (Motherwell)
“I think that the scoreline (1-0) flattered us, to be honest. I felt that our levels were as poor as they've been. Three major elements, technically, tactically and physically. I just didn't think we were at the races from the first minute. It probably took us 81 minutes to make one pass with penetration and then the pitch started to open up. We're not going to paper over the cracks by saying that Craig Gordon makes two absolutely brilliant stops to keep us out and thinking that we should have had a draw because we shouldn't have. I think Hearts should have been out of sight." | SNS Group

14. Valdas Dambrauskas (Omonia)
"I believe he has not changed the style but maybe the shape and some principles. Instead of inverted full-backs, suddenly the full-backs stay wide and there is a clear structure. Players know exactly what to do and I think it's not a coincidence that the team won with a good score on Saturday. When this happens, a manager has an impact, it gives the team momentum." | SNS Group

15. Simo Valakari (St Johnstone)
"Hearts used their moments with better quality than what we did. We could not produce enough moments in the final third. Our crossing, final pass, was not good enough. We asked more questions second-half. The most disappointing thing is that we worked so hard to get back into the match, and a couple of minutes later we are 2-1 down." | SNS Group

16. Patrick Cregg (Brechin City)
"In the first half I felt we shaded it and it would have been a fair reflection if we had gone in 1-0 up at half-time. We had belief at half-time that we could win, but as the game went on Hearts took over and they were the better team. I’m extremely proud of the players in terms of the effort they put in." | SNS Group

