Aberdeen claim penalty shout vs Hearts 'ignored' as Dons star and Derek McInnes incident addressed

A penalty appeal has emerged from Hearts 1-0 Aberdeen alongside a sprinkling of aggression.

Aberdeen boss Peter Leven says his side were denied a penalty against Hearts - as he weighed in on an incident between Derek McInnes and Dennis Geiger.

A Claudio Braga goal was the difference in a 1-0 win for the top of the table Jambos who go into a fortnight’s break top of the Premiership. They have nine games to play as they seek a historic league title and put on a dominant display to edge out the Pittodrie side, despite the narrow margin of victory.

Interim gaffer Leven was left unhappy after Stuart Armstrong went down in the box after half-time under a challenge, with nothing given by the officials. Ahead of a midweek tussle against Hearts’ title rivals, Celtic, Leven called back to Aberdeen defender Liam Morrison’s recent dismissal against Dundee as a similar situation.

Should Aberdeen have had penalty vs Hearts?

Leven said: “I thought we started alright in the first five minutes, then we looked a wee bit nervy after that. We never picked up second balls, the gaps were too big, we let Hearts into the game and the fans here responded. We didn’t threaten them enough either. Second half was a little bit better, but overall, in the final third, not good enough. Too many shots getting blocked, not enough end product for me.

“We had a good penalty shout ignored in the second half. We got a player sent off last week when the Dundee player cut across Liam Morrison. For me it was similar on Stuart Armstrong. Someone gets across him, it’s not shoulder to shoulder. He actually leans in the back of him with a knee as well. I don’t know why it’s not a penalty.

“It’s a disappointing result. The top six is still just about achievable, but right now, we’re not picking up any points. We’ve got a tough game on Wednesday, but we’re at home. We need to start picking up points. We need to stand up. We all need to take responsibility for that. Sometimes it’s good after a loss to get back on the pitch straight away, so we’re looking forward to taking Celtic on.”

What happened between Aberdeen player and Derek McInnes

At full-time, there was an accusation that Hearts boss McInnes had nudged Aberdeen midfielder Geiger in the back. An on-field scuffled ensued between players and staff with Leven questioning McInnes about it, and the Aberdeen gaffer had his say post-match too.

Leven said: “He said McInnes nudged him in the back as he walked past him. I asked him (McInnes) the question: ‘Why is my player saying you nudged him in the back?’ He said he didn’t.”

McInnes had a short and simple response: “We shook hands there, he's fine. It wasn't me that pushed him, I don't know. So we're fine, we shook hands. He wasn't happy, but I don't know, it was fine. No issues there. We've got to realise that when you say now ‘nine games to go’, it doesn't seem a lot, but 27 points is still a lot that can happen. I just think that it was just important we dealt with our game.”

News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice