Celtic continue red card rage after Hearts clash as they can't fathom SFA decision on Tynecastle flashpoint

Celtic have had an appeal over a sending off in the game with Hearts chucked out.

Celtic have hit out at the SFA’s decision to throw out an appeal over Auston Trusty’s red card against Hearts.

Debate has stirred for days after the 2-2 Premiership draw after the American international was handed marching orders for a foul on Jambos striker Pierre Landry Kabore. Referee Steven McClean initially branded a yellow card but VAR official John Beaton sent him to the monitor, and the decision was then deemed denial of a goalscoring opportunity.

It was appealed by Celtic amid complaints by boss Martin O’Neill post-match but the SFA have stuck by the decision. It’s left the Premiership side currently third and six points off the top far from pleased, as they struggle to understand why their appeal has been thrown out.

Celtic response to SFA on Auston Trusty incident

They said in a statement: “Celtic's appeal over the red card shown to Auston Trusty in the draw against Hearts at Tynecastle on Sunday has been dismissed, following a Scottish FA hearing today (Tuesday). Clearly we are very disappointed at the outcome of today’s appeal.

“The VAR Protocol requires that VAR only intervenes when there is a 'clear and obvious error’. It is difficult to see how the original yellow card decision is a clear and obvious error and accordingly, VAR’s intervention by the refereeing team was not consistent with the rules. We await the written judgement but will be ensuring further discussions with the SFA on the matter as we seek to understand the rationale for this and other decisions.”

The SFA simply stated on the outcome: “Claim dismissed. Red card for sending off offence A4 – Denying the opposing team or an opponent a goal or an obvious goal scoring opportunity as defined by Law 12, is re-imposed with immediate effect. £650 Appeal Deposit to be paid within 30 days.”

What Celtic said about Auston Trusty red card

As they sit two games off Hearts, captain Callum McGregor says the Hoops need to be perfect between now and May, as he disagreed with the sending off. He said: : “It’s certainly not been easy, but I don’t think that’s been the case for anyone. When you’re so successful and you win so much and then you go through a spell where you’re struggling, the team are struggling, then of course it’s difficult. Let’s not hide away from that. Obviously, you know the games that you have to get something from.

“Sunday was a game we had to get something from and now you need to be pretty much there or thereabouts and obviously other results will determine that, but we can only focus on what we can do. To be honest, it’s probably one if he gives a red off the bat, you’re probably not too surprised.

“But when he gives the yellow, I think the only question is, is that an obvious enough error to then go to the monitor? I’m not sure. But again, I think if it went either way, you kind of have to accept it. It’s one of those grey area ones.”

Related topics:
News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice