Former Celtic star claims Hearts could earn 'bottle job' label if they fall short amid title race dominance

The former Hoops and Aberdeen man has been a serial Hearts doubters since the start of the Premiership season.

Charlie Mulgrew once predicted that Hearts would finish eight points behind Celtic in the title race - but he also believes if the Jambos stumble from this point on it would be a ‘bottle job’.

Hearts slipped up last weekend in Kilmarnock as their Old Firm title rival got back within touching distance. Celtic now sit two points adrift of the league leaders, while Rangers are three points behind. There are now just eight games to go in the SPFL Premiership season as we approach the all-important split.

While Mulgrew admitted he’d rather be in Hearts’ league position than that of their fellow contenders, the former Scotland International also believes that there is now an air of expectation around Tynecastle since they’ve dominated the league for so long. The Jambos have been top of the pile for almost the entirety of the season and at one stage boasted an eight point lead.

Hearts collapse would see them earn ‘bottle job’ title - Mulgrew

Speaking alongside former Hibee Kevin Thomson on The Breakdown podcast, Mulgrew said: "First of all, Hearts have put themselves in a right good position. I think if you'd have offered them at the start of the season that they would be here with eight games to go, they'd have bitten your hand off for it.

"But now, you're there and have been in that position, I think if you don't go and get it from now, it will be a sore one. There is no doubt about it. Those Hearts players and staff have laid in bed at night dreaming and thinking this is a possibility. To not get it will hurt. Is that a bottle job? Bottle job might be a harsh word but considering they have got themselves in this position, aye, it would be.”

Hearts’ defeat to Kilmarnock came at a less than ideal time with both Celtic and Rangers winning last weekend. Mulgrew believes the key now for Derek McInnes’ men is to see how they react to the setback, starting with Dundee at home this Saturday.

Mulgrew assesses key to Jambos title success

The former Celtic defender also was wary of Hearts’ form when they go behind in games compared to when they get their noses in front. He continued: “That’s where I think Hearts may struggle, I don’t know the stats on it, but it would be interesting to find out how many times they’ve been behind this year.

“I think when they get in front, they’re really hard to break down but when they go behind it’s a different story. I know earlier on in the season they came back from 3-0 down against Motherwell, but generally, I’d like to know how many times they’ve been behind so far.

“They’ve got Dundee on Saturday now. For me, Hearts are still in the driving seat because they’ve responded every time this year. They’ve proven they can respond to a defeat and that could be key. They won’t go under and it’s still Hearts’ to lose.”

The Scottish Football Social Club is presented by BetSBK.com | 18+ | Gamble Responsibly

News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice