Transfermarkt value = €450kplaceholder image
Transfermarkt value = €450k | SNS Group

Hearts and Hibs combined XI: football transfer experts best Edinburgh team based on 'market value'

Hearts may be top of the Scottish Premiership but rivals Hibs are well represented in a combined ‘most valuable’ starting 11.

We are in for one more Edinburgh Derby this season with both Scottish Premiership leaders Hearts and rivals Hibs guaranteed to finish in the top half of the table when the league splits.

The Jambos have won both contests at Tynecastle 1-0 this season while the Hibees were 3-2 victors at Easter Road, showing how evenly matched the two have been when facing off. It raises the question, that so many punters will debate in pubs and living rooms across the city, about how a combined starting 11 from the two squads would look.

Using the current ‘market values’ of players at the two clubs, provided by football transfer website Transfermarkt, this is what the best combined XI looks based on their current transfer value:

News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice