Hearts: How they rated in the Scottish Cup victory over St Mirren

How the Hearts players rated in the 4-2 Scottish Cup quarter-final victory over St Mirren at Tynecastle Park.

Saturday, 12th March 2022, 9:43 pm
Updated Saturday, 12th March 2022, 10:38 pm

After a number of injuries against Dundee United Last week, Robbie Neilson was forced to ring the changes, with three under-18s players on the bench.

He set out his team in the 4-2-3-1 formation that’s been used successfully in recent weeks, with ever-versatile Andy Halliday dropping into left-back and Stephen Kingsley partnering Craig Halkett in the middle of the defence.Peter Haring replaced Cammy Devlin, with Ben Woodburn handed a start in attack.

Craig Gordon 7/10

Ellis Simms and St Mirren's Alan Power compete for the ball in a thrilling Scottish Cup tie at Tynecastle

No chance with either goal. Was called into action several times though and made the saves when required.

Nathaniel Atkinson 7

Had his ups and downs defending against the tricky Jordan Jones and maybe not 100 per cent fit but good going forward.

Andy Halliday 7

Utility man made key interception early on and generally defended well. Not afraid to get forward either.

Craig Halkett 9

Bandaged up after three minutes, and put in another warrior-like performance. Relished the physical tussle with Eamonn Brophy.

Stephen Kingsley 8

Just as comfortable at centre-back in a back four as he is in on the left of a three. Solid, terrific on the ball and came close with a free-kick.

Beni Baningime 7

First goal for club wasn’t a thing of beauty but welcome nonetheless. Booked in 40 minutes but certainly played his part.

Peter Haring 9

Will earn a new contract with more performances like this. Strong, composed on the ball and finished his goal superbly. Should have had two.

Ben Woodburn 6

Zipped in a superb first-time ball for Haring’s goal. Had his moments, got into decent positions but execution let him down too often.

Liam Boyce 8

Linked up very well between the midfield and Simms in attack. Slipped a few dangerous through-balls behind the Saints defence.

Barrie McKay 7

Deployed mainly on the left, he caused the Saints defence lots of problems. A constant threat.

Ellis Simms 7

Plenty of endeavour from the on-loan Everton man and he was in the right place inside the six-yard box to get his goal.


Aaron McEneff 8

For Woodburn 67 mins. In the six-yard box, scored with first touch seconds after coming on, then cross for Simms to score the fourth.

Toby Sibbick

For McKay 93mins.

Message from the editor

Thank you for reading this article. If you haven't already, please consider supporting our sports coverage with a digital sports subscription.