St Johnstone boss warns about potential 'negative spiral' as Hearts bound McPake urged to maintain levels

Simo Valakari praised the Scottish Championship’s top scorer but has said he must maintain the standard he set in the first half of the season.

St Johnstone manager Simo Valakari has addressed the situation surrounding top scorer Josh McPake, who has agreed a pre-contract deal to join Hearts next season.

The Perth club are top of the Scottish Championship and the former Rangers attacker has been their star man as they look to return to the top flight at the first time of asking after last season’s relegation. The 24-year old has scored 12 league goals for Saints this season, putting him four ahead of a chasing pack of four other players on eight in the race for the second tier golden boot.

Valakari was full of praise for McPake, but also had a warning message for his player. The Finnish head coach says he must stay fully focused on maintaining his McDiarmid Park form in the second half of the Championship season or risk entering signing for the Jambos on the back off a ‘negative spiral’.

“Josh needs to be even better, when you go to another club you need to go there with momentum’ - St Johnstone boss Valakari on Hearts bound McPake

Speaking to The Courier, Valakari said: “What I know is that Hearts sent us their letter of intent last week. Since that, there has been no contact.

“The talks are between Hearts and Josh now. If this opportunity comes for Josh, I am very happy for him. It tells me that he has done good things for himself and his team.That’s how it should be.

“I want for every player here that they put their heart and soul into our team and then I know when they move on that they have done good things for our club. That’s why it’s important that we don’t feel offended or threatened if there is interest in our players or they choose to go there.

“All I ask of my players is that they are open, honest, transparent and give this club everything while they are here. I always see it as a win-win situation.

“We had a talk during our pre-match meal on Friday, three hours before the game. We have a good relationship, and the talks were very open. I demand a lot from him, as I do all our players.

“Nobody has done anything wrong. The rules allow a player to negotiate and sign a pre-contract. Josh has a very good relationship with our fans. I think he wants to walk out as a hero and have this status of a player who is remembered in a positive way.

“If anything, he should be more focused on making sure that happens. If things don’t go well people will make wrong assumptions like: ‘This is why he jumps out of a challenge’. So, Josh needs to be even better.

“Plus, when you go to another club you need to go there with momentum. If he’s not doing a job for us here, not playing well, he would go there on a negative spiral. Hearts coaches and players will be watching him.

“If he goes there with goals, assists and wins for our team his standing will be much higher with a new club. Also, if a pre-contract gets signed there is less pressure. He can enjoy his football.

“Pre-contracts are very common in football so there is no drama. We want to keep him as long as possible, but we know our realities.”

News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice