Hearts loan plan and the future for youngsters at Riccarton
Tynecastle coaches remain committed to developing talent from their academy
As the Scottish Football Association discuss youth development issues with the Scottish Professional Football League this week, it is a pertinent issue at Hearts. Alongside, Celtic, Rangers, and Aberdeen, the Edinburgh club simply are not giving enough first-team game time to academy graduates under the age of 21 for the liking of the governing bodies. It is something Riccarton coaching staff are acutely aware of and are in the process of addressing.


The Scottish FA’s Transition Phase report published last month highlights the problem across several leading clubs. Between 3 April, 2023, and 2 April, 2024, the percentage of Premiership minutes played by under-21s was worryingly low. Hearts gave 5.8 per cent of minutes to under-21s, Rangers 5.5 per cent, Aberdeen 2.7 per cent and Celtic only 0.9 per cent. For comparison, Motherwell devoted 17.1 per cent of minutes to under-21 players, Dundee 13.4 per cent, Hibs 12.4 per cent, Kilmarnock 9.5 per cent and Ross County 6.1 per cent.
Those statistics prompted this week’s meeting to discuss potential solutions. The SFA’s chief football officer Andy Gould and head of men’s elite strategy Chris Docherty are convening with the SPFL’s competitions working group in an effort to force change. One idea is to allow under-21 players to move on loan at any time of the year to avoid being bound by transfer windows. The Hearts head coach Steven Naismith harbours a degree of doubt over what will actually be implemented, but he acknowledges the need to improve youth development in Scotland.
“The report is damning. It highlights a lot but I'm sceptical on whether there will be change,” Naismith told the Edinburgh News. “It's just another example. You look at leagues finishing early through Covid. You can go back every 10 years. There are opportunities to do something for the good of the game or we could have our individual agendas. That's every club.”
Hearts and Celtic both operate B teams in the Lowland League, the fifth tier of the Scottish football pyramid. Naismith would like to see them competing in the top four tiers within the SPFL. “It's a good idea in terms of restructuring the loans, but it's also a good idea having B teams and having them in the leagues,” he added. “By that, I mean in the SPFL. If you research the best smaller nations and the most consistent players at major tournaments, they play in countries where B teams play competitively within the league system.
“We have a bit of that with the Lowland League and we think it's good. We have found benefits from it, but I think it can be better for the whole of Scottish football. Now, that won't suit some teams so they will push that agenda and other teams it will suit will push theirs. It needs a collective attitude of everybody sitting down and parking the individual agendas. I'm not convinced that will happen but I do agree it should happen.”
Any new rule must be carefully thought out to ensure maximum opportunities for younger players at first-team level. The loan system in comparable countries like Croatia and Hungary lets players join lower-league teams from the age of 16 to gain senior experience. Croatia reached the 2018 World Cup final and the 2022 World Cup semi-finals. Scotland failed to qualify for both tournaments.
Naismith is not keen for any resurrection of the previous rule which decreed matchday squads had to include a certain number of under-21 players. “When I was coming through as a player, the three under-21s on the bench rule didn't work because you just had young guys missing games with the under-18s or reserves because they had to sit on the first-team bench,” he recalled. “They couldn't go on loan because they were needed to fill the under-21 quota on the bench. They were never going to play so you end up killing their progressing and that just didn't work. We are sitting at the same point so it needs to be something of substance.”
At Hearts, 17-year-old striker James Wilson, 19-year-old midfielder Macaulay Tait and 20-year-old midfielder Finlay Pollock are waiting to learn their fate. All three have been unable to establish a place in first-team squads on matchdays this term and consequently find themselves in the B team. They can join lower-division Scottish clubs on loan up until 30 September and Tynecastle management have received a number of enquiries.
The Hearts players under 21 who are currently out on loan are midfielder Aidan Denholm (20) at Ross County, defender Bailey Dall (20) at Stirling Albion and goalkeeper Liam McFarlane (19) at East Fife. Naismith is aware of the need to develop more youngsters at first-team level. With his team presently bottom of the Premiership after a dire start to the season, he is understandably reluctant to risk inexperienced players in a high-pressure situation.
“It's a tough part because we have everybody fit and we have consistently had a large squad fit. We have brought more players in at the moment,” he said. “For me, it's still a big thing I want to push. The ones we have on the cusp of the first team at the moment are the most likely and I think they can all be Hearts players. The hard part is this short-term, getting them involved. There is the potential that a couple of them might go on loan but there is also the argument for keeping them here.
“The jump from B team training to first-team is big so they need to get used to that. I think they have got used to that to a point over the last year. If we do send them out on loan and there are a few injuries, then that opportunity is missed for them. It's a fine balance. It's at the forefront of my mind that I want to get young players through into the first team and be regulars in the first team.”
Pre-season training saw all of the above working in amongst the senior Hearts squad, aiming to establish themselves ahead of the new campaign. “We are sitting where we are at the moment because all of those young players through pre-season had the best opportunity to show: 'I'm better than the players here, I'm going to play'. They did well but I don't think any of them did enough for us to go: 'We need to seriously think about him starting games.' That's a learning thing,” explained Naismith.
“For Macaulay and James especially, last year was a breakthrough season. The second season is always difficult because training with the first-team and being in that dressing-room has become normal. You lose that wee bit of an edge. You then need to find that so that the desire for you is to get into the first team and stay there. We need to navigate these next few months but I do expect, by the end of the season, we should have a few of them regularly in the squad and playing minutes.”
