Hearts red card vs Livingston questioned as 'guesswork' fears clash with top UEFA official's advice

The Birmingham City loanee was sent off in Hearts’ clash with Livingston.

Pundits Michael Stewart and Alan Hutton have questioned Marc Leonard’s red card for Hearts against Livingston - as fears are cast over how denial of a goalscoring opportunity dismissals are being handled.

The Birmingham City loanee will miss Saturday’s crucial Premiership clash with Motherwell after referee Kevin Clancy displayed a red for his tackle on Livi forward Robbie Muirhead. Leonard and Muirhead were in the Hearts half but it was still deemed sufficient enough for the DOGSO ruling to be applied after a VAR review.

Ex Hearts midfielder Stewart, Rangers hero Hutton and host Darrell Currie have debated the on-loan Birmingham City man’s marching orders on the latest Premier Sports Social Club show. Currie’s previous guidance off a top UEFA official was noted as what warrants the denial ruling was debated.

What is DOGSO in football refereeing?

Stewart started the conversation with: “We did say a couple of weeks ago, when's it going to be that there's a foul in the opposition half that's given us a red. The officials and SFA may well not like the criticism that comes particularly from here, but I've got to say, you came out with the stat or the guidance from the top, top referee in UEFA level, Champions League. If you look at an incident and you think to yourself how many times are they going to score out of 100 from that incident, and if it's not approaching 40 or 50, I think it was that you said...”

Currie interjected with: “A couple of years ago I had a conversation about DOGSO. The whole point was it has to be over like 30-40 % you need to know, if it's an obvious goal scoring opportunity, to really go through with the red card.”

Stewart came back in and added: “I just think when you're looking at that it's in the opposition half. You can see Jordi Altena running back through the middle. There's so many other variables. I just think for a denying a goal scoring opportunity, you're talking about fouls hat are in the final third, that type of thing. I think once you start getting towards the middle of the park, or in the opposition half, I just don't think you're looking at those instances. How often does a player pick a ball up and running with it do they get a shot away, never mind scoring a goal, just getting a shot away?”

Marc Leonard Hearts sending off assessed

Hutton insisted that there is consistency being shown across the board but that doesn’t mean calls are correct. The ex right-back said: “It’d be interesting taking all they players away and seeing how many goals you would score through there. Like, you're running through on goal, are you going to score nine or 10 out of 10?

“Probably not. To be a red card from there and I'm listening to everybody. I'm trying to watch as much as I can and see what everybody's opinions are. They're saying that it's a straight red and you're denying a goal scoring opportunity.

“if I take a touch forward and hit it for 50 yards, and it's on target, does that count? It's like, come on. In the Premier League I don't think you're getting sent off for that in my opinion. I've said it before, they're looking for consistency and they've got it, but I just think it's consistently wrong in my opinion. I think some of them are just way too far and you have to take the distance into consideration. You have to because people are guessing ‘oh that player's not going to make it back or that player's too wide,’ they're not going to get back. How do you know? That's just guesswork.”

The Scottish Football Social Club is presented by BetSBK.com | 18+ | Gamble Responsibly

News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice