Hearts rescue Stuart Findlay from a weird Oxford United spell with no contact from managers
EFL stint is coming to an end after Tynecastle deal
There is palpable excitement from Stuart Findlay when talking about Hearts and the security they have just given him. Agreeing a two-year contract, effective this summer, allows the 30-year-old defender clarity on his future. The feeling is rare for a player who spent the last three years unsure where he would play each season. He is, therefore, somewhat relieved to finally be moving on from Oxford United.
Findlay is on loan at Hearts from Oxford until the end of the season, at which point his contract with the English Championship club expires. He hasn’t even spoken to their last two managers and long ago accepted he had no future at the Kassam Stadium. Findlay joined Oxford from American side Philadelphia Union in 2022, made 44 appearances in season 2022/23 and then appeared to be deemed surplus to requirements.
He played on loan at Kilmarnock for two years before following manager Derek McInnes to Hearts in another loan deal last summer. Findlay is grateful to McInnes for the faith shown in him. Totally out of the picture at Oxford, he is an integral part of a Hearts team sitting top of the Scottish Premiership. So, when the opportunity to settle in Gorgie permanently was put in front of him, he couldn’t get the lid off the Biro quickly enough.
“I've been at Oxford. It doesn't seem like I've been there, but I've been there for a long time,” said the player. “At the end of the day, you know that with your contract, you're not going to be unemployed in the next year. When you realise you've got a year left and you come on loan to a club like Hearts, the best-case scenario in the world would be to get off to a flier in the first six months and be able to get something organised. The way it's worked out, I honestly couldn't have dreamt of anything better. I'm just delighted to get it done, and now I can just look forward to, hopefully, a really good couple of years.
“I think, when I spoke to you guys a couple of weeks ago, I sort of put it out there that I was interested in it. I sort of teed myself up for it. Obviously, when you've got a year left, you're still a loan player, that's what I was. But as soon as you go to the six-month stage and you know that you're a Bosman, then as soon as the club approached me and said it was something they were interested in, I had no interest in looking elsewhere. I said to my agent: 'I want to get it done.' It's probably the most I've enjoyed my football in a long time, and it makes perfect sense to continue it for another two years at the end of this year. As I said, as soon as the club came, there was no other option in my mind.
“Oxford is a bit of a strange one. I knew from the time I went down, the first time I was told that I didn't really have a future at Oxford. You think from the fact they've had two or three different managers since that the situation might change, but I've sort of had the same story to the point that I've not spoken to the last two managers. I've never been contacted by them. I think Oxford sort of just seen me as a player that they had, that it maybe didn't work out the way they did, which is fair, this happens in football. I've been on loan the last two years and I've not had much contact with them, if I'm being honest.
“When the Hearts thing came about, it wasn't as if I had to talk to Oxford about it. It was sort of done above me and I was more than happy to have it done early. The fact of the rejection part from Oxford, I maybe got hit with that after the first year when I was initially told I could find a new club. Since then I've sort of got used to it and I've been able to thrive at the clubs where I've been on loan, where I've felt that I've been trusted the way that I hope that I can be.
“To be honest, I don't want to talk too much about Oxford. The last couple of years have been a bit of a strange situation. They've never really seen me as an option to be around the place, for whatever reason they believe. When Hearts came in over the summer, for a loan, they showed absolutely no hesitation in letting me go. As soon as Hearts came in with a permanent deal, to be somewhere where I feel as if I'm wanted, it's a nice feeling. I've not had that feeling for three years off a parent club, so to be able to come here and be able to get that sort of deal done, yeah. Oxford, once I've got six months left, it's sort of out of their hands, and I was more than happy to come at Hearts. It made perfect sense for me.”
For each of the last three summers, Findlay has been waiting to learn where he will play his football. Two successive years at Kilmarnock under McInnes laid foundations for a jump to Edinburgh with Hearts. The player is delighted that fate dealt him a kind hand. “Definitely. The last three years, it's been strange. You get to the end of every season and it's as if, even though you're contracted, you know that your financial situation is safe, you've got the hesitancy of not knowing where you're going to live, not knowing if you're going to have to pack up your rented accommodation.
“To be able to get that sort of security, and know that I can relax, and I'm going to be in the one place for a couple of years, it's massive for me and my family. When you add in the fact that it's Hearts, who are on the sort of trajectory that they're on, it makes it a lot easier as well. Everything about the sort of situation made sense to me.
“My family have been great. My wife's been around the block with me. She packed up the things and moved to America [in 2021, and just as she got comfortable in America we came back over to Oxford. So, she's learned the hard way what it's like in the life of a footballer's wife. As soon as the Hearts idea came up and I mentioned it to my wife, she was more than happy for it to stay the way it is. We're settled, we're happy where we are. I'm happy football-wise. Our stars are all aligned, and it was the easiest decision I ever had to make.”
Findlay rejected the chance to sign for Hearts in 2021 to accept the Philadelphia move. He doesn’t regret it. “I've tried a lot of different situations in my career. I've tried the MLS, I've tried something completely different,” he explained. “Probably at the time it wasn't as common as it is now. I went to Oxford, it probably didn't work out the way I wanted. I was able to work with the manager at Kilmarnock. When he gets the job to come to a massive club like Hearts, you've got a massive club that want you, you've got a manager who trusts you, you've got a manager you like to play under, and you're playing well.
“When you put all those things together, to want to try something else again, it made no sense to me. Everything's going the way I want it just now. I couldn't have picked a better six months than what we've had. When you've got the chance to continue that for two more years, it was a very easy decision to make. When I chose not to go to Hearts the last time, it wasn't anything to do with looking at where I thought the club was. It was just that there was an option on the table at the time which was something that I'd maybe never get a chance to do in my life again, and it's an option that I had to take. I don't regret my choices at the time.
“It was an experience that I'll never forget, but the only thing I had was a tinge of doubt of 'maybe I'm not going to get that chance again'. When it came back up, I wasn't going to miss it the second time. I was hoping it was going to go well, but if you'd told me it would go this well so far, then maybe even the most optimistic of Hearts fans might have disagreed with it. It couldn't have gone any better. To be able to just be able to keep my working relationship with the manager, but to do it at Hearts as well, as I say, everything just clicked into place at the right time.”
On the very distant horizon is the World Cup finals. Scotland have qualified, Findlay has one cap - and one goal - which came back in 2019. Playing consistently for the country’s league-leaders will surely mean he is at least looked at by Steve Clarke and national team coaches? “I don't think there's any football player in the world who wouldn't want to play at a World Cup, who doesn't want to represent their country, it's the pinnacle for any player,” he acknowledged.
“I made my debut a long time ago now, it was the proudest night of my career and it will be until the day I retire. I know the manager of Scotland well and I trust him a lot to make sure that he makes the right decisions. He's a manager I've got a lot of respect for and he's picked boys that have got to three major championships for a reason. He knows what he's doing. All I can do is make sure I perform well for Hearts and make sure that if any opportunity does arise, that I put myself in a position where I could be looked at. That is out of my hands. That's up to the manager there. All I can do is put in a performance for Hearts and, if anything comes off the back of it, then it would be a massive bonus. I'd be very glad to be involved.”
On a lighter, and more immediate, note, Findlay is embroiled in competition with Hearts team-mate Craig Halkett. The two centre-backs are trying to outscore one another this term, and Halkett’s header against Livingston last week put him 6-5 ahead. There is no prize or forfeit but that doesn’t lessen the intensity. “It's purely bragging rights but in the car school with him that's a lot. That's high enough stakes,” said Findlay.
“Just as I made it five-each he comes back in and makes it 6-5 again. We have a joke about it. I think the fact you have the little joke, the little competition, that almost makes it more of an incentive to get the goals but it's funny that halfway through the season I've already got my record tally and I'm still one behind him. I'm trying as hard as I can but he is one ahead just now and I'm sure he'll remind you of that if you ask him.”
