John Robertson in Hearts title race verdict as icon spots moment at Livingston that'll leave McInnes 'raging'

The Hearts icon was on punditry duties as the Jambos drew at Livingston.

John Robertson insists Hearts are still where everybody else will want to be after a 2-2 draw with Livingston narrowed their Premiership title race advantage.

It proved to be a disappointing weekend for boss Derek McInnes and his players, as they slipped up against the Lions who are still awaiting their first league win since August, while Rangers and Celtic won against Dundee United and Dundee. Stevie May put Livi ahead but Lawrence Shankland and Claudio Braga goals put Hearts in command.

A poor ball out from the back by Craig Halkett allowed the Almondvale side to counter and Lewis Smith eventually tapped home after a botched Joel Nouble effort to see the shares spoiled. Marc Leonard was sent off in second half stoppage time and will now miss next weekend’s crucial game with Motherwell at Tynecastle.

Livingston 2-2 Hearts verdict

Robertson was on punditry duty for Sky Sports and reckons the nature of Livingston’s second goal will leave McInnes far from pleased. That said, with a one-point lead heading into the final game pre-split, the former Hearts striker still feels it’s positive in a psychological sense for his ex-side to remain top amid a setback.

He said: “They go top, that's the big thing. Hearts are back on top, so psychological, that's good for them. They'll be disappointed though, because at 2-1, they were comfortable. Really, really comfortable. It's schoolboy stuff. You don't play a straight pass into a midfield man, he gets caught and they spring, they end up from probably one of the worst misses of the season getting a goal from it.

“But after that, Hearts didn't really do enough to win the game. I don't think the last half hour that they asked enough questions of Livingston defence, asked enough questions of Livingston goalkeeper. In the end, you've got to say it's a fair result. Hearts, between the two Livingston goals, could have put the game to bed but they didn't. It's a straight ball to the midfield, it's one from a defensive point of view, it's so, so easy to get that, that's a poor pass there.

John Robertson on Hearts title chances

“It's a hell of an assist there from Nouble but Derek McInnes will be raging about the straight pass into midfield. It's straight in there and then this one, it's a red card. Anybody from a non-Hearts persuasion will look at that and go, oof, that's two points dropped. We saw Celtic have problems at Livingston, we saw Rangers have the same score, 2-2.

“Derek McInnes will be disappointed because from the Livingston goal to the Livingston second goal, Hearts were in complete control, could have scored three, four, maybe even 5 goals, but didn't, and at 2-1 we were all sitting thinking, one more goal, that's it, but they didn't, they switched off one for the slack pass, and Livingston had a couple of wee squeaks towards the end where they might have nicked it, but they'll come out, top of the league, still top of the league, and that's where you want to be, and we go again, it's another week.”

The Scottish Football Social Club is presented by BetSBK.com | 18+ | Gamble Responsibly

News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice