Celtic in blistering VAR blast amid red card vs Hibs as ace's incident with Easter Road star sparks ref demand

The Hoops have released a statement claiming VAR was trying to ‘re-referee’ the initial decision at Celtic Park on Sunday.

Celtic have expressed their dismay at defender Auston Trusty losing his appeal for the red card he picked up against Hibs in the SPFL Premiership.

The American International appeared to strike Jamie McGrath during a Celtic corner as the pair were jostling for position in the box. While referee Matthew MacDermid thought a talking to for both players would suffice originally, after being sent to the monitor by VAR Grant Irvine, he decided to send off Trusty for violent conduct. The dismissal had a huge bearing on the game as Hibs picked up their first victory at Celtic Park since 2010.

Celtic decided to appeal the Trusty red and have lost the decision meaning the club now have to pay a £650 fine. Martin O’Neill will also have to be without his mainstay at the back for the next three Scottish Premiership matches against Rangers, Aberdeen and Motherwell. Following the loss of the appeal, the club released a statement expressing their frustrations with the decision.

Celtic statement on Trusty appeal loss

The Hoops statement read: “We are hugely disappointed at today’s decision, which will now result in Auston Trusty being suspended for three matches after an “arm to arm” contact as he looked to release himself from being held prior to the ball coming into play - the kind of incident which features in games across the country week in week out.

“The match audio demonstrates that the referee saw the incident clearly. Immediately following the incident, the referee said: ‘It's nothing I’m just going to speak to them’ in terms of no further action being required. In discussions with Celtic Manager Martin O’Neill after the match this was something he also confirmed.

“However, VAR again decided to intervene to ‘re-referee’ an initial decision which had been made. While we await the written judgement, this and other decisions in the match and in other recent games demonstrate a serious issue with VAR and its current deployment which needs urgently reviewed.”

Martin O’Neill on Trusty dismissal

The Celtic boss’ initial thoughts were: “I've just had a word with the referee. He said he was going to just have a word with the two players then VAR intervened and said it was violent conduct. You can't do this if that's the rules now. It doesn't matter if someone is holding on to you. You can't, in an attempt to break away, you can't thrust down in the manner in which he did."

It isn’t the first time this season Celtic have appealed a Trusty red card as he was also given his marching orders at Tynecastle in January for a tackle on Pierre Landry Kabore for the denial of a goalscoring opportunity (DOGSO). While Celtic claimed there were covering defenders, O’Neill’s appeal was also lost and they were forced into another fine.

The Hoops boss now has a huge decision to make regarding who he slots in at centre back in place of Trusty ahead of three mammoth fixtures. O’Neill could either give one of the youngsters a chance, such as Brentford loanee Benjamin Arthur or Dane Murray, or he could play the more experienced Kieran Tierney in a more central defensive role where he has played in the past.

News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice