Ifs and buts are the lingua franca of football folk, the history of this maddening game absolutely awash with instances of maddening misfortune, baffling refereeing decisions and incomprehensible brain malfunctions conspiring to undermine the very best efforts of many a manager. And, as Hibs directors talk amongst themselves about a truly horrendous start to the current league campaign, they may draw some consolation from the knowledge that they shouldn’t really be sitting bottom of the Scottish Premiership.
Had an over-zealous VAR not intervened to gift Dundee United a penalty just over a week ago, remember, David Gray’s men would have been two points better off. Sitting 10th. Above Hearts.
And yet … even allowing for all of the problems inherited by Gray, nobody – least of all the gaffer himself – is arguing that Hibs have met minimum expectations in the first dozen games of this Scottish Premiership season.
This isn’t the dream they sold season ticket holders when the renewal emails were going out. Current reality bears zero resemblance to the picture painted when Bill Foley’s £6 million buy-in, complete with promise of extensive Black Knight co-operation, was voted through at the last AGM.
How bad is it? With just one win on the books, and that against a St Johnstone team who promptly sacked manager Craig Levein for the riddy factor of losing to this Hibs side, Gray cannot point to any substantial achievement in defending his position.
Here’s how Gray’s record, in those first 12 league games, compares to the results of his previous FIVE predecessors. You will honestly be stunned by the identity of the gaffer who tops this mini-table of Hibs managers …

5. Jack Ross W5 D3 L4 - Points: 18
He was the one, wasn’t he? The guy Ron Gordon shouldn’t have sacked. Hey ho. Ross made an impressive start to his two years at Easter Road, kicking off with back-to-back wins over Motherwell and St Johnstone in November of 2019. Although two of his four losses came against Rangers and Celtic, his Hibs team were also toppled by Livingston and Ross County as he got to grips with the challenge of taking over a team mid-season. Photo: Ross Parker - SNS Group

6. Paul Heckingbottom W6 D4 L2 - Points: 22
Whodathunkit? There were only 13 league games remaining when Heckingbottom took over in February of 2019. The former Leeds boss started with a run of three wins and, most importantly, won his first derby – a 2-1 victory at Tynecastle. Undefeated in his first 10 Scottish Premiership matches at the helm, Heckingbottom’s Hibs did rather fall off a cliff over the closing games of the league season, losing to Rangers, Kilmarnock and – in his unlucky 13th league game in charge – Aberdeen, although they finished fifth. | SNS Group

