Hibs named Premiership title contender as Hearts joined by 'underrated' rival in dream four-way fight

A claim has been made by one pundit when it comes to Hibs mixing it with Hearts, Rangers and Celtic.

Hibs have been backed as a dark horse in the Premiership title race - as one pundit holds hope for Hearts and David Gray’s side challenging Old Firm silverware dominance.

There’s been plenty of chatter this season about the Jambos making a move to bring the top flight trophy outside of Glasgow territory for the first time since the 80s. They sit seven points clear at the top of the table ahead of a busy winter schedule but Hibs have started the campaign in solid fashion themselves.

After a third place finish last term, a 3-0 win at St Mirren before the international break cemented Gray’s men in that position, behind Celtic and their city rivals. Pat Nevin has been watching over the Premiership and reckons Hibs are flying under the radar, currently ahead of Rangers. He reckons both sides of Edinburgh can make a fist for the top prize.

Can Hibs win the Premiership title?

The ex-Scotland international told CasinoHawks: “It could even be a four-way title race. I still think Hibs are underrated at the moment. That's not just because of my green and white scarf. Because I've watched them, and the fact is, like they did last season, their results aren't as good as their performances. Then they went on a bad run last season early on then improved. So, you know, they could do that again. I would like it to be a four-way fight. I would love a Glasgow v Edinburgh four way battle.

“I think it's possible this season that it could actually happen. We could get all four not that far away from each other come the end of the season. The one that actually I would be worried about Rangers, because Europe's been so terrible for them. They've changed their manager. It's just not clicked. It really hasn't clicked.

“Whereas now and again, I watch some of the odd games, like the semi-final against Celtic, they went down to 10 men. They took it all the way. And Rangers played some pretty good stuff. And you think, there's a team there. There's absolutely a team in there somewhere. The problem is nobody's been able to find it yet regularly.”

Could Celtic strengthen in January?

Champions Celtic could throw some money at the January transfer window to help maintain dominance with Liverpool and Scotland star Andy Robertson rumoured as one possible option. Nevin added: “Andy Robertson to Celtic? That's a bit weird. But here's a thought, and it's a weird thought. Do you remember Martin O'Neill when he was at his very best managing Celtic? He played a back three.

“If you have Kieran Tierney and you have Robbo for a little while, Tierney can play left centre-back in the back three, and Robbo could play a little bit wider and further up. That's where Robbo's strengths are. And when you have those two flying down the line, which I've seen them do for Scotland, they are bordering on unstoppable.

“Even so I think it's going to be slightly surprising. It's a lot of money for a player who isn't young. It would be mostly wages, right, but it's still quite a bit. But would it look good? Yeah, it probably would.”

News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice