How humiliated Hibs rated in Dundee United debacle - report from biggest EVER home loss to visitors

Momentum generated before international break lost in a single afternoon of ineptitude and indecision

Humliated, humbled and hung out to dry by Dundee United, Hibs suffered their heaviest defeat of the season on a day of mutiny in the stands and mediocrity on the field. Having gone into the international break flying after Hampden heroics against Hearts and a first league win under Marink Reedijk, they suffered a catastrophic loss of altitude and momentum to a United side making history with their biggest EVER victory at Easter Road.

A Zach Sapsford double book-ended the first half for Jim Goodwin’s men, who were gifted a third early in the second half before going 4-0 up on the hour mark. On a day of truly abysmal individual and collective performances by the home side, no-one could complain about fans abandoning their posts in droves as goals number three and four hit the net.

They’d seen enough long before time up, their patience exhausted by a performance devoid of quality or fight. The only consolation for these players is that there were so few left in the stadium to voice their displeasure at full-time.

With Hibs showing just one change to their starting line-up, Alex Williams picking up where he’d left off as an extremely early substitute for Felix Passlack in the pre-break dismantling of Aberdeen, Reedijk’s had no excuse for not maintaining the momentum built before the shut-down. Maybe even make a quick start?

With just five minutes gone, however, the home side found themselves in trouble, a simple ball down the inside left channel causing all sorts of problems in the penalty box, culminating in Jason Kerr conceding a penalty in a tangle of legs with Sapsford. The striker’s penalty was saved by Raphael Sallinger – but he buried the rebound to make it 1-0 with seven minutes showing on the clock.

The Hibs defence looked jittery and ragged too often during those opening exchanges, a Lyall Cameron corner to the back post finding Will Ferry unmarked. The home side were living life on the edge, in and around their own penalty box.

Going forward, well, the main problem for most fans – many of whom made their feelings known – was simply that their team didn’t do that often enough. Square balls and backwards passes were booed and jeered.

Hibs did manage to create chances, though, with one Josh Mulligan cross from the right giving Joe Newell the chance to test United goalkeeper Jack Walton with a powerful header only just turned behind. Owen Elding was less convincing from a Jack Iredale cross, while Martin Boyle’s failure to finish a chance at the back post seemed to sum up the lack of threat in the home ranks.

But basics let them down for the second United goal, as a short throw-in on their left wing found Kevin Ciubotaru one-on-one with Jamie MCGrath, who did not do nearly enough to prevent the cross from coming in. Sapsford timed his run to get ahead of Kerr and score with a thumping header at the near post.

Worse was to come just six minutes into the second half, as a horrible square ball by Boyle triggered a truly unfortunate series of events for the home side. A post was hit, tackles were lost, defenders stood frozen – and not even the linesman’s flag could save them as, after a VAR check, Cameron’s looping shot into the net was deemed a goal, after all.

As angry as supporters obviously were, Reedijk’s fury was equally clear. The fact that he quickly made FOUR changes in one substitution break, throwing on Thibault Klidje, Rabbi Matondo, Callum Wright and Nicky Cadden as Owen Elding, Josh Mulligan, Joe Newell and Jack Iredale all made way.

Things did not improve. In fact, they got worse, United bagging a fourth within three minutes of the substitutes coming on, Jesse Randall given time to pick his spot with a low left-footed shot from the edge of the box.

A fair few Hibs fans had headed for the exit when the third goal went in. The fourth was the prompt for a mass exodus.

United supporters, meanwhile, treated their hosts to a rousing rendition of the greatest anthem in club football, Sunshine on Leith. It hits different, when it’s intended to take the mickey.

Yes, Hibs might have bagged a consolation goal. They could also have lost a fifth and sixth, with Raphael Sallinger looking increasingly shell shocked between the sticks.

Reedijk’s men, back here on Tuesday night to face Dundee, face a short but necessarily brutal bout of introspection before returning to duty. Here’s how we rated them on an afternoon they’ll want to forget:

News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice