Hibs ratings and report as VAR penalty decision impacts on battle for Europe in Livingston stalemate

First clean sheet in 26 games for Scottish Premiership bottom side as Gray’s men held to a standstill

Hibs saw a late penalty award overturned on a frustrating day at Easter Road, as David Gray’s men failed to fully capitalise on Motherwell’s slip-up in the race for fourth place. On a day when Jamie McGrath hit the woodwork twice, the home side had to settle for an infuriating goalless draw against Scottish Premiership bottom side Livingston - who recorded their first clean sheet in a remarkable 26 games.

In a game short of excitement, it looked as if Martin Boyle – now in the home straight of his Hibs career – had secured his team a golden chance to take three precious points when he went down under the challenge of Mo Sylla with just over a minute of the 90 remaining. Referee Lloyd Wilson immediately pointed to the spot.

But the match official was called over for an on-field review by Video Assistant Referee Greg Aitken. And, after a quick check, reversed his decision.

Hibs had dominated possession and territory all day. But failure to break Livi down ultimately saw them settle for a point that moves them to within six of Motherwell, who lost at Celtic Park.

Against a Livingston team content to sit halfway inside their own territory in a 5-5 formation, Hibs were always going to find chances at a premium. Still, McGrath did hit the bar with his second bite at a well-worked corner routine, the midfielder also seeing a deflected effort scrambled off the line by goalie Jerome Prior in a first half short on excitement.

Nicky Cadden’s deliveries at least provided a consistent threat in a packed penalty box, Owen Elding coming closest to converting as he sent a flashing header beyond the far post. Livingston’s only chance of getting a goal was on the counter-attack and, when they squandered a two-v-one break against Rocky Bushiri early in the second half, the visitors looked out of ideas.

The introduction of Martin Boyle and Dane Scarlett for Jack Iredale and Ante Suto saw Hibs switch to virtually a 4-2-4 formation, throwing bodies forward in search of the breakthrough. They gave up some possession. But did create chances.

Boyle should have buried one from six yards. And fellow substitute Josh Campbell somehow blazed over from the same distance after Prior had saved Dane Scarlett’s first shot heading into the closing 10 minutes.

There was more drama to come. But not, alas, a goal that would have given Hibs enormous momentum heading into next weekend’s trip to Fir Park.

News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice