Hibs season in review: Questions of style, late goals conceded, European adventures - and a lot of frustration

Easter Road side still have chance of securing 50-year European first

The final act always influences audience sentiment. And failure to deliver a crashing crescendo to a frustrating campaign makes it impossible for Hibs fans to feel overly joyous about season 2025-26; nobody is organising open-top bus parades for a team finishing fifth.

As everyone at Easter Road takes time to reflect on ten months of grinding graft, occasional highs and too many near misses, however, it’s important to bring a degree of perspective to any judgement. Especially as this footballing year could still end with Hibs qualifying for European football – something they haven’t done in consecutive seasons for half a century.

Do memories of Midtjylland and a historic Old Firm away double combine to compensate for domestic disappointments? Or do famous wins against the biggest teams – proof that David Gray’s men could mix it with the best in Scotland – merely add to frustrations over what might have been, with a little more consistency?

Let’s break down the good, the bad and, yes, the occasionally ugly. To figure out where Hibs need to improve, as much as anything else.

European adventures

It all seems a very long time ago. But you can’t underestimate how much fun Hibs had on their return to European football.

Mighty Midtjylland, a side who would go onto batter Celtic before losing out on penalties to Nottingham Forest in the last 16 of the Europa League, needed extra time at Easter Road just to get through the second qualifying round. There was a genuine feeling that Hibs had just been damned unlucky to run into such an established force so early in the competition.

Beating Partizan 2-0 in Belgrade, meanwhile, stands out as a genuinely impressive away result – by any Scottish club – in an era of too many meek surrenders on foreign soil. And, over-officious policing aside, what a night Hibs fans had in Warsaw …

Yes, supporters were left thinking about what might have been. Legia were there for the taking. But you could hardly call the campaign a failure.

Consistently inconsistent

One six-game unbeaten run between mid-February and early April hinted at the potential for Hibs to put together a strong series of results. But their longest winning streak, over the course of the entire season, stood at just three matches.

The truly infuriating thing was their ability to pull awful results out of nowhere. They’d be trotting along well enough … and then trod on a rake in full Sideshow Bob style.

Late goals conceded were a problem, to say the least. So too were complete off days like January’s numbing 4-1 thrashing in Falkirk.

And the entire season could probably be summed up by one week at the end of February. It began on a Sunday afternoon at Celtic Park, with Hibs picking up their first away win over the Hoops in 16 long years.

By the following Saturday, however, they were throwing away two points at Dens Park in maddening fashion. Very on brand.

Old Firm pair humbled

How to follow up that historic win over Celtic in Glasgow? Why, by defeating Rangers at Ibrox – a far more regular occurrence of late – in a dramatic final week of the season.

To put it in perspective, Hibs hadn’t defeated both Old Firm sides away from home since season 1984-85, when neither of the Glasgow clubs even came close to lifting the title. That means something, right?

Mixed fortunes on derby day

Played four, lost three, won one. Not a great record against Hearts, is it?

But there are circumstances. So many circumstances. Two late goals conceded in narrow defeats at Tynecastle. Going down to NINE men at Easter Road.

In keeping with the overall theme of the season, frustration abounds when reviewing all four Edinburgh derby encounters of the campaign. In large part because Hibs were so very, very good in the 3-2 home win over Hearts back in December.

That victory against the league leaders – far more comfortable than the final score suggested - proved, or so we thought, that Hibs could aim high. Should aim high.

What the numbers tell us

Virtually every available metric underlines the idea that Hibs have been a middling sort of a team, over the course of the entire campaign. Ranked fifth in goals scored AND goals conceded per match, Gray’s men were sixth in big chances created and seventh when it came to touches in the opposition box.

A little attacking inconsistency shouldn’t be much of a surprise for a team who sold star striker Kieron Bowie in a deal worth up to £7 million midway through the season. And, while stats are helpful, they always tell an incomplete picture.

A question of style

Here’s the rub. There aren’t many Hibs fans who have really enjoyed watching their team – at least not on a domestic front – over the past 10 months.

Losing to Dunfermline in the Scottish Cup, regardless of how well Neil Lennon’s men have done since, and slipping to any number of disappointing Scottish Premiership results has contributed to the sense of frustration. There was also a real sense of opportunity missed in failing to take advantage of a poor Rangers side in the League Cup, as Russell Martin’s men were given very little trouble by Hibs at Ibrox.

Throw in repeated missed chances to overtake Motherwell, right up until the final game of the season, and it all adds up to something underwhelming. And, when you’re not winning, focus inevitably turns to entertainment value.

In a year when Hearts have stolen the headlines, Celtic have lifted the biggest prize and Motherwell have earned all the plaudits for their style of play, Hibs have fallen into a sort of hinterland in the public consciousness. Most neutrals barely think about them at all.

Are they a bad team? No. There have been times when they’ve played with pace, intent, brains and brawn.

Had Josh Mulligan, Nicky Cadden and Jamie McGrath all remained fit and available for the duration, they would have been a far more attractive side. Something to look forward to next season, then, right?

News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice