Sloppy, sluggish and sub-par Hibs were sent crashing out of the Scottish Cup in sickeningly inevitable fashion on a bleak day in Dunfermline, as former gaffer Neil Lennon masterminded a victory over his old club in dramatic fashion. An injury-time own goal from substitute Miguel Chaiwa, the midfielder deflecting the ball past Raphael Sallinger from a corner, saw David Gray’s men exit the competition in the fourth round.
And they could have no complaints about the result after failing to match the energy, hunger and drive of their lower-league opponents. They were off the pace from virtually the opening seconds. And duly paid the price.
Even on a calm day in the Kingdom of Fife, Hibs were always going to face a storm of sorts. If there’s ever been a Lennon team who didn’t start a game quickly, the guilty men will undoubtedly have heard about it.
And a lack of accuracy in the visitors’ play led to a scrappy first half when they came under sustained spells of pressure. They certainly allowed Dunfermline to put in too many crosses for the liking of the large away support.
Still, Kieron Bowie should have made it 1-0 to Hibs with 38 minutes on the clock, the Scotland striker racing clear from halfway to collect a Junior Hoilett pass and close in on the Dunfermline goal. Given too long to think about his opportunity, the big man hit a tame shot straight at the legs of Deniz Mehmet.
The home side came roaring out into the second half like men possessed, immediately cranking up the intensity and putting Hibs under the cosh. Raphael Sallinger was forced to make one truly fine stop from an Andy Tod rocket just two minutes in.
That sparked a response from the away side, who at last started to bring a bit of oomph to their final-third play. Junior Hoilett was the best of the men in dark green, forcing Mehmet into a fine save with a thumping shot – and generally making a right royal nuisance of himself in and around the Dunfermline penalty area.
The arrival of Nicky Cadden and Dan Barlaser from the bench gave Hibs a more familiar look. And club record signing Thibault Klidje really should have scored with his final touch of the game, heading straight at Mehmet just before being replaced as Gray again went to his substitutes.
But Hibs could not gain momentum. They could not find a way to put Dunfermline under sustained pressure. And the coup de grace, coming moments after Sallinger had denied the home side an opener, felt as inevitable as it was painful for the visitors.

1. GK Raphael Sallinger 5.5/10
Made some big saves. Could do nothing about the goal that killed his club’s Scottish Cup campaign stone dead. | SNS Group

2. RCB Warren O'Hora 5/10
Had to a do a lot more defending than he would have liked. Takes his share of the blame for loss. | SNS Group

3. CB Rocky Bushiri 5/10
A first start since returning from his AFCON adventures for the big man, who brought his usual physicality to the battle. But that’s all. | SNS Group

4. LCB Jordan Obita 5.5/10
Arguably the best of the back three, especially once Nicky Cadden’s arrival at wingback allowed him to get forward more often. | SNS Group