I watched Hibs vs Celtic from the press box: Five things I spotted including red card debate and Deja Vu
Here’s what we spotted watching Hibs against Celtic on Sunday in the Premiership.
It was a case of Deja Vu for Hibs against Celtic as they lost 2-1 in the Premiership.
Having lost 2-0 to Motherwell last Tuesday after conceding two quickfire goals at Fir Park, compounded by a Grant Hanley red card, they conceded twice inside 60 seconds against the champions. Hibs put up a sturdy showing for the majority of the match and cut into Celtic’s lead with a Martin Boyle penalty but it wasn’t enough to claim any spoils.
Next up for Hibs is Falkirk at home and a victory will be required if they are to avoid three defeats in succession. We watched the game from the press box at Easter Road and here are five of the things we picked up on.
Fluid shape
There was a question asked in the media gantry of when was the last time Hibs played a back four. It appeared on paper that Jordan Obita had moved into left-centre-back but out of possession at times, Hibs appeared to have the look of a four-man defence, as opposed to their usual three central defenders routine. Over the piece it did appear as though they were operating out of their usual defensive formation but that little bit of flexibility did seem to give Celtic trouble in the opening 20 minutes, particularly down the sides, where a big chance was created for Boyle. Obita was bombing past Nicky Cadden and Warren O’Hora had licence to step up towards the halfway line.
Warning on the left
It’s not an issue for now but Sunday showed the type of problem that could occur at Hibs in the next six weeks or so. N. Cadden went down injured in the first half and Obita was also withdrawn, partly tactical, but partly due to some tightness. Neither injury appears to be overly concerning Gray but Obita will be with Uganda at AFCON over December and January, leaving N. Cadden as the sole natural option out there. Perhaps left-side of defence will be an area they look to address in January.
Deja Vu
What will leave Gray most frustrated is the manner of the goals. The first is an error and you can’t really account for that when it comes to individual moments, but the second is perhaps more lamentable. Hibs didn’t switch on after the setback and Celtic took full advantage. They were far better after resetting at half-time but there will be an emphasis on response to adversity, you’d feel, leading into Falkirk.
Possible red card for Celtic?
It was a challenge that warranted a yellow but debate has stemmed over whether Colby Donovan’s first half slide on Obita could have been more. VAR backed up Nick Walsh’s on-field decision but ex refs Steve Conroy and Des Roaches, via their Ref’s View platform, said “That is a red card every day.” Chris Sutton said on Sky Sports commentary: “He gets sucked in here, Donovan, and it’s a reckless challenge on Obita. Wild that from Donovan.”
Gray said post-match: “I've not seen it back to be honest, so I don't really want to comment on that. I never thought about it. Now that you're saying it, I didn't think at the time anything other than a yellow card. I thought it was a yellow but I've not seen it back so I don't really think it's right to comment on that.”
Home reinforcement
The basis of Hibs’ ascent to third place last season was their solid form at Easter Road, which brought about 10 wins from 19 with just three defeats over the entire campaign. So far this term, they’ve won twice from their seven matches at Easter Road, albeit the two defeats have come against both sides of the Old Firm. Their record is nothing to be concerned about at this juncture in the season but with Falkirk, Hearts, Aberdeen and Motherwell in their next four at home, that’s a far from easy run of games. Capturing the essence of last term will be key in this quartet against three sides currently in the top six, and the other in Aberdeen sit seventh amid improving form.