Analysis

John Greechan: I watched Hibs crash out of the Scottish Cup in meek fashion - here were my 3 key conclusions

Huge travelling support angered by flat performance in Fife

Meek, bleak and entirely predictable. Any more adjectives you’d like to attach to a defeat that sounds some serious alarm bells for Hibs?

Even without its famous cemetery backdrop, East End Park’s reputation as a place where complacency goes to die should have been enough to warn the visitors against taking anything for granted in today’s brutal Scottish Cup takedown by Neil Lennon’s battling Dunfermline. Should have.

So what conclusions should we draw from a fourth-round exit that punches a huge hole in the schedule for David Gray’s team? And where, exactly, to they go from the crushing low of losing to Championship opposition in such an oddly bloodless manner?

Questions over selection are a distraction

Yes, you can argue that it probably wasn’t wise to hand Joe Newell his first start in over a year in a game of such importance. Not many neutral judges, meanwhile, would have given Thibault Klidje – club record signing or not – a starting place against an opposing back three capable of bouncing him all over the park.

Leaving hindsight to one side, however, virtually ANY team picked by Gray – heck, any random selection generated by a hallucinating AI machine – should have had quality enough to overpower Dunfermline. Who are not a brilliant team, by any stretch of the imagination.

The lack of accuracy in virtually everything Hibs did, from passing to closing down, picking up runners to stopping crosses, must be a huge concern to Gray and his coaching staff. If nothing else, it’s a reminder to players that good performances don’t just happen.

Hibs haven’t exited the Scottish Cup at this stage since season 2017-18. They’ve reached the quarter-finals in each of the last two campaigns.

So this exit is going to hurt. And it should.

We need to talk about Thibault …

While no official figure was ever confirmed, Hibs were happy to reveal that they’d broken their club record to sign Thibault Klidje from Swiss side Luzern in the summer. It was understood that the deal easily broke the £1 million barrier for the first time in Easter Road history – with some estimates putting the final valuation at nearer £1.5 million.

The chance he missed against Dunfermline was emblematic of his struggles in this first season of Scottish football. He’s scored four goals in all competitions. Has turned in the odd promising performance. But isn’t exactly pulling up trees in the SPFL.

In a January window where Kieron Bowie has attracted plenty of chatter but no concrete offers, a situation unlikely to be influenced heavily by the Scotland forward’s own missed sitter against the Pars, Hibs remain in the market for another forward. The return of Martin Boyle, at least fit enough to come off the bench at East End Park, will help.

But it doesn’t reflect well on the recruitment department, a much-improved arm of the football operations at East Mains over the past 18 months, that their big summer purchase is proving so ineffectual. Especially in a game where they really need quality to trump effort.

A repeat Euro adventure is now a must for Hibs

Just shy of 5000 Hibs fans – the official allocation of 4700, plus a good couple of hundred quietly lurking in a sort of neutral zone in the main stand – travelled to East End Park in anticipation of a grand day out. Those still there to acknowledge the players after full-time weren’t slow in making their feelings known.

Look, the relationship between supporters and team is never a one-way street. The Easter Road faithful lived up to that billing by maintaining belief in Gray and his boys during the darkest days at the start of last season – and were well rewarded with not merely a club record unbeaten run, but an enjoyable, if all too brief, European adventure.

Defeat to Dunfermline now removes the prospect of silverware, the one thing guaranteed to win over any fan base, from the immediate future. So what would fans settle for, in its place, to consider this campaign a success?

Well, a lot may depend on what happens at the very top of the Scottish Premiership. But finishing third for the second season on the spin – a feat that has proven beyond so many teams over the years – would surely get the job done, in the eyes of punters.

At the very least, they’ll want another crack at Europe to show for their loyalty and devotion. Not unreasonable, given the circumstances.

News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice