Where Hibs MUST do better - Edinburgh derby data in focus as Hearts head to Easter Road chasing title boost

Cut out the late concessions, create more chances - and let the match winners shine in spotlight of white-hot rivalry

Two late heartbreakers and a dominant victory that, courtesy of a late flurry by the losers, ended up being just a little more nervy than it needed to be. If we’re looking to the immediate past for hints and omens of things to come at Easter Road this weekend, well, it’s clear that there hasn’t been much between Hibs and Hearts – at least not in head-to-head encounters – in a season of contrasting fortunes for Edinburgh’s two major clubs.

But there are definite indicators, if you look beyond the three-game aggregate score of 4-3 in favour of Hearts, behind the headline numbers attached to the fixtures. Reasons, perhaps, why Derek McInnes’ men are still sitting top of the Scottish Premiership. While David Gray’s side are still chasing fourth place.

If Hibs are to maintain their recent impressive record in home derby encounters, Gray will be looking for improvements in a number of crucial areas. So let’s take a look at parts of this game, in particular, where the Hibs report card is likely to be marked “Must do better.”

Play the full 90 – and beyond

Start with the obvious, right? Craig Halkett won the first derby of the season for Hearts with a 93rd minute goal. Thomas Magnussen was positively early with his winner at Tynecastle in February, striking with a full two minutes of the regulation 90 remaining.

If those two away losses were painful for Gray’s men, part of the agony comes from knowing that they were so close to walking out of Gorgie with creditable goalless draws. No wonder the Hibs boss makes mention of Hearts consistently finding a way to get the win.

Even in the home win over the Jambos, meanwhile, Hibs were caught with a couple of late blows. Three up early in the second half of a game sandwiched in between Christmas and New Year, the Easter Road side were always going to come under sustained late pressure as the visitors rallied in search of a lifeline.

But conceding to Lawrence Shankland with 15 minutes to go, before Cammy Devlin generated some late tension with a strike just a minute from time, felt like an unnecessarily nervy way to finish things for a Hibs side who had absolutely dismantled their nearest and dearest rivals in the opening hour. Not that any Easter Road regulars would complain about the same outcome this weekend.

Does possession matter?

This has become something of a culture war issue in football at times. For some, the issue of actually having the football is treated as a tenet of absolute faith in the philosophy of winning.

Others see any mention of possession as proof that the world has gone mad, because, to paraphrase the argument: “In my day, you could just kick it long, get ‘em turned – and still have a smoke on the top deck of the bus on the way home …”

In the wider context of the league, neither Hibs nor Hearts are particularly wedded to the idea of controlling the ball for long spells. The league leaders are fourth in possession averages, while Hibs are sixth – and there isn’t every much in the numbers.

In their three meetings to date this season, however, the numbers could hardly be more confusing. Last time out, as Hearts won 1-0 at Tynecastle in February, possession was split 52-28 in favour of the home side.

Back in October, Derek McInnes side enjoyed a walloping 62 per cent possession. Yet even that wasn’t the biggest gap recorded between the sides this season.

In that 3-2 home win over Hearts in December, Hibs managed to outplay and out-score their opponents with just 33 per cent possession. Go figure. And don’t forget to show your work.

Make more chances

This is where Hibs have really struggled against Hearts. Despite hitting the net three times in that festive win at Easter Road, the official FotMob stats show that Gray’s men have created only four ‘big chances’ over the course of the three games.

Their combined expected goals (xG) tally for the three fixtures comes in at a little over two. If Hearts haven’t exactly ripped open the Hibs defence in those encounters, with similar numbers posted, they have at least played with a bit more attacking intent.

Total over 3 games so farShotsOn targetTouches in opp boxxG
Hearts3812683.19
Hibs229402.32

In shots and shots on target, the Tynecastle side have out-performed their rivals. Some of that may, of course, be due to home advantage. But redressing that balance will give Hibs a better chance of bagging a vital win on Sunday.

Let star men shine

The last time Hibs beat Hearts, Jamie McGrath was the top performer on either side, the Irishman bagging a goal and assist. Nicky Cadden wasn’t far behind, the wide man also setting up a goal.

Other stand-outs on the day? Josh Mulligan and Kieron Bowie. Ah well, someone will need to step into their rather large boots, obviously.

The loss of Mulligan to injury, even if it has been off-set by the energy of Miguel Chaiwa, has changed the dynamic of that Hibs midfield. McGrath has to do more, without the ball, and occasionally finds himself two or three yards deeper when his team get a chance to counter.

Up top, Hibs have filled the £7 million hole left by Bowie well enough. Owen Elding is definitely a handful. But Martin Boyle has scored one goal in 2026, while Dane Scarlett is yet to find the net for Hibs since arriving on loan from Spurs in January; super sub Ante Suto looks an obvious choice up front, although he’s genuinely looked better coming off the bench.

Stop the Hearts threats

Shankland, obviously. Claudio Braga, naturally. And Alexandros Kyziridis, to boot. Plus those runners from deeper in midfield.

As David Gray points out, Hearts being top of the Scottish Premiership is no accident. They’ve got threats all over the park.

Hibs will have a plan for neutralising those danger men. And will be aware that McInnes has shown the ability to switch his team’s formation, without making a single substitute, with a click of the fingers.

In their three meetings so far, Hibs have allowed Hearts 38 shots, with 12 of those hitting the target. The Gorgie side have also accumulated 68 touches in the Hibs box over 270 minutes plus change.

You can’t expect that sort of pressure not to pay off at some point. Blunting the direct and energetic Hearts attack will be crucial, if Hibs are to get the result they need.

News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice