Malky Mackay lands Hibs backing as ex star who lived Easter Road transfer chaos sees value in key market

The Hibs sporting director has been put under the spotlight in recent weeks.

A former Hibs star has backed Malky Mackay to work his way out of fan disgruntlement at Easter Road - after witnessing signing chaos first-hand in Leith.

The sporting director has helped the club make it’s next managerial pick ahead of a new era. Now 2016 Scottish Cup winner David Gray has been sacked, ex-Beveren boss Marink Reedijk replaces him, with a section of fans protesting against Mackay in the pre-international break draw with Aberdeen.

Aiden McGeady reckons sporting directors can outlast several managers but things not working out always bring spotlight to their own positions. He’s backing Mackay to see out the noise though and work quietly in the background to improve Hibs.

Malky Mackay at Hibs assessed

He said: “A director of football normally has a little bit more time. They can normally see off about three managers before real questions are being asked. But when the recruitment's being questioned, and there's been quite a lot of scrutiny on the recruitment this season that's when obviously, not questions have to be answered, but that's when you're in the spotlight. And it's inevitable.

“It was David Gray the last couple of weeks but when David Gray goes, it's the next person in line that gets it. But directors of football are always able to normally because they're not the ones that really face the media. They're normally in the background. They don't really do a lot of press conferences. So they're normally shielded to an extent. Then again, obviously directors of football are normally in the process of picking managers as well.”

Summer recruitment largely done in the EFL has come under fire too but McGeady was at Hibs in the Lee Johnson era four years ago when 15 players including him signed during one summer. Players signed that window endured varying degrees of success, from Rocky Bushiri, to Momodou Bojang.

McGeady has worked in the scouting department at Wigan Athletic during his post-playing days, and insists Hibs signing Kieron Bowie from Fulham before selling him on for a club-record fee is evidence of that market still proving fruitful. He explained: “I think value for money is in the eye of the beholder, isn't it? You could pay £500k for someone who turns out to be an absolute bargain, that's probably worth five or six million, like Kieran Bowie. He is probably the prime example.

Hibernian's Rocky Bushiri signed in the same summer as McGeady.placeholder image
Hibernian's Rocky Bushiri signed in the same summer as McGeady. | SNS Group

Hibs recruitment assessed

“There were probably question marks over him because he was at Northampton, I know he was at Fulham as a kid, and stuff like that, but there is value for money down there. Probably more so than you probably would get in Scotland. If you're competing with other teams in Scotland, your rivals don't want to sell to you, and you're going to have to pay a premium. I think the first season under David Gray the recruitment was really good.

“Then you lose some players. Recruitment is really hard. I mean, you're taking a chance on someone, and the chances are it's probably one out of three, one out of four, that probably hit the ground running, and then you have to probably persevere with the rest.

“Then maybe another couple might come good eventually and then there's always one that's probably written off pretty much immediately. Going back to my time there, the recruitment was all over the place. I know it's changed now, obviously with Malky McKay as sporting director When I was at Hibs we brought in, what, 15 players in the summer? I think Lee Johnson was wanting rid of like 11 of them by the January.

“So there's been historic battles with recruitment and paying players off. I think I remember there were certain players who had to get paid off and who still had years on their contract from when I was there. Can you get value for money in England? Of course you can, because I think obviously the market that Hibs are shopping in isn't Championship, it's League One and it's League Two and it's Premier League 2 players.”

Aiden McGeady was speaking in association with NewBettingSites| 18+ | Gamble Responsibly

News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice