Three Motherwell vs Hibs referee and VAR decisions in focus as IFAB outline clear penalty rules

Here are a few of the referee and VAR decisions that sparked debate from Tuesday night’s clash.

VAR and refereeing talking points have stemmed from Hibs’ 2-0 loss at Motherwell midweek, in their latest Premiership quest.

A calamitous first half had David Gray’s side conceding twice, once from the penalty spot, and then seeing Grant Hanley sent off. That was too much to overcome as the hosts implemented their possession-based style to dominate the rest of proceedings and move themselves level on points with Hibs, who remain third.

There were several talking points from the match, including decisions made by referee Duncan Nicolson and video assistant referee Greg Aitken. Here’s the verdict on three of them from a busy night in North Lanarkshire.

Motherwell penalty vs Hibs

Aitken ushered Nicolson over to the monitor for a second look after an Elijah Just shot hit Hanley in the arm before going out for a corner. Although the ball was struck from close range and looked to be going wide, it was awarded a penalty. It comes off the back of a weekend where VAR was criticised for failing to award Livingston a penalty in their loss at Rangers, when Tete Yengi’s seemingly on target shot looked to have came off the arm of Emmanuel Fernandez, but nothing was awarded.

The Ref’s View, a podcast hosted by ex-referees Steve Conroy and Des Roache, tweeted via X with relation to the Fernandez similarity: “Two very similar handball incidents but two very different outcomes- why? Surely the same ‘coaching’ should lead to the same decision?”

Lawmakers IFAB define handball as follows: “It is an offence if a player deliberately touches the ball with their hand/arm, for example moving the hand/arm towards the ball. Touches the ball with their hand/arm when it has made their body unnaturally bigger.

“A player is considered to have made their body unnaturally bigger when the position of their hand/arm is not a consequence of, or justifiable by, the player’s body movement for that specific situation. By having their hand/arm in such a position, the player takes a risk of their hand/arm being hit by the ball and being penalised.”

Hibs red card vs Motherwell

This one hasn’t had any major protests. Tawanda Maswanhise broke the defensive line Hibs were trying to hold and went down under a challenge by Hanley. There was a lengthy VAR check and it contributed to six minutes of added on time in the first half but eventually after being called to the monitor, Nicolson handed out a red.

Gray said: “I've got no complaints about the red card (for Hanley) because of the letter of the law. Now, if he's onside and he's brought down and you're the last man, that's a red card because it's outside the box. It's an accidental trip, I think. So, that is a red card. We've signed up to VAR and the technology, we can argue about that, whether I think it's good enough, the lines are good, it doesn't matter. It's a factual decision that we've all signed up to.”

Possible Motherwell red card vs Hibs

The one that VAR didn’t send Nicolson to the monitor for. Gray was left miffed in his post-match presser having watched goalscorer Maswanhise appear to flick his head towards Hibs defender Jack Iredale in front of the technical areas. VAR didn’t warrant the incident worthy of a second look for Nicolson.

Speaking on the incident, Gray said: “I do think there was one that I think Maswanhise gets away with in the first half. I've seen it with my own eyes, which is the only reason why I think he gets away with it. I've not seen a camera angle to confirm it, to be honest. So, I'm not going to blame anybody for that. I don't know what VAR looked at. But the linesmen have seen it. I've seen it. My goalkeeping coach has seen it. He tried to back head-butt Jack Iredale. I mean, he doesn't quite make contact. But if I make an action to go forward and try and head-butt somebody … he can't do that.

News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice