Italy 18-15 Scotland: Report and player ratings as Italians navigate the Rome rain better in Six Nations scrap

The hosts came out on top as the heavens opened at the Stadio Olimpico.

Scotland’s ill-discipline, poor game management and wayward lineouts were to blame for their opening weekend loss to Italy in the Six Nations.

The Scots had a point to prove from their disappointing Autumn Nations Series campaign and also needed to right the wrongs of their last trip to the Stadio Olimpico, when they were defeated 31-29 two years ago. Gregor Townsend named nine of the same starters who featured that day in today’s XV.

One thing you do expect in Rome is a passionate Italian national anthem, however something you mightn’t predict would be rain, as Townsend’s men appeared to bring the weather with them to the capital. With four kicks within the first two minutes, the narrative of the match was set from the get-go.

The ball was like a bar of soap in the opening exchanges but it was the hosts who struck first as they attacked after Grant Gilchrist gave away a penalty for holding on. After a successful resulting lineout, Nacho Brex kicked the ball into acres of space for Louis Lynagh to score in the corner. Thankfully for the Scots, Paolo Garbisi skelped the post with the conversion.

Scotland had a chance to reply instantly with a penalty 30 metres out but opted to go for maximum points. This proved to be a waste as the Italians grabbed the resulting lineout. They would regret this decision even more just two minutes later, as Lynagh just pipped Jamie Dobie to a high ball from scrum half Alessandro Fusco. With a numbers advantage down the left hand side, a looping pass from Michele Lamaro to Tomasso Menoncello played the centre in for an easy score. This time Garbisi was able to add the extras.

After a sustained period of Scotland pressure on Italy’s five metre line it was only a matter of time until the defence of the hosts cracked. After several phases and two penalties which Ewan Ashman tapped and ran, the in-form Glasgow number-eight Jack Dempsey touched down under the posts, to give Finn Russell an easy conversion.

Scotland were momentarily forced into an early change when Nathan McBeth came on for Pierre Schoeman as a blood replacement. Italy then added three for a penalty given away by Scott Cummings for jumping across the lineout. After a bizarrely casual missed drop goal attempt from Garbisi just 15 metres out, he eventually added the three points from the tee. As the rain reached biblical levels towards the end of the half, Garbisi tried another drop goal attempt but once again was wide of the mark. They then ran down the clock to go into the break 15-7 ahead.

With an eight point deficit going into the second half, the winner of this year’s Cuttitta Cup was going to come down to who could manage the conditions better. The handling errors from the Scots were understandable given the rain, however the lack of kicking for territory was mind-boggling. Another poor lineout from Ashman gave the Italians an opportunity to break through the defence through Menoncello. This time the defence stood firm, but the lack of communication from the forwards was becoming a real worry.

Scotland got it back to a one score game from the boot of Russell who opted to take the points from an easy penalty under the posts. As the Italians gained territory from the resulting kick-off, some superb work in the ruck earned Scotland a penalty. However, this was then overturned by the TMO as there was a high tackle from Ashman in the build-up. The good news for Scotland was it was a penalty and nothing more, the bad news was Garbisi took the Italians lead back up to eight.

Ashman was soon replaced as the experienced George Turner came on, however he was shown a yellow card left under review almost instantly for a hit on Manuel Zuliani, who suffered a nasty injury from the whack. The refereeing team agreed that the mistimed tackle from the veteran hooker only warranted a yellow.

The lengthy stoppage killed some of the momentum in the game but Scotland regained territory in the Italy half 10 minutes later. With 15 to go, they were awarded another penalty but once again kicked for touch instead of going for the points. After a maul which nearly included all 30 players, replacement George Horne ended up with the ball and sneaked into the corner. Russell wasn’t able to to convert from a tough angle.

With Scotland three points down on the eighty minute mark there was no margin for error, which was easier said than done with a wet ball. But after nearly 30 phases, the Italians defended resolutely to hold Max Williamson up and claim the 18-15 victory.

News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice