Three huge Scotland selection decisions facing Gregor Townsend ahead of 2026 Six Nations
The current Scotland squad seemingly has more quality in depth than ever before and that could mean it’s time for some big selection calls.
Another Six Nations full of so much promise for Scotland is on the horizon as we once again try and temper our expectations having had our collective optimism put to the test time and time again.
It feels like every year there are voice saying ‘this time is different, this could be our time’ and those of us that bang that drum are inevitably left with egg on our faces. Only this time, there really does feel like cause to believe this is a side capable of going all the way to the final game still in contention for the title.
Gregor Townsend named his 40 man squad on Monday as the inclusion of experienced forwards Dave Cherry and Jonny Gray took the headlines. What went under the radar slightly was that this group of players is the first in a long time that will have supporters seriously debating potential test match selections.
For the past few years the starting XV has picked itself and there has been little if any debate over most positions. That’s not inherently a bad thing but it does also demonstrate the worrying lack of depth the team has had to work with in recent times.
When you can so easily name the starting line up it’s not just because the players in those positions are so good but because the next player in line to replace them is so far behind in the test level pecking order. In 2026 that is far from the case and Townsend now has some serious selection calls to make.
1. History vs form and the rise of the Glasgow Warriors’ wingers
Edinburgh duo Duhan van der Merwe and Darcy Graham have a combined 69 tires in 104 caps at test level and are fighting a mini battle between themselves to be Scotland’s all time top try scorer with van der Merwe currently ahead by two. Despite that, neither are guaranteed to be nailed on starters this Six Nations.
Kyle Steyn and Kyle Rowe would be the next in line behind them but displacing two test level beasts is a tough ask. The former South Africa under 20 cap brings the size and unrivaled running power, not to mention the X factor he loves to show against the English with ball in hand, while Hawick boy Graham balances that beautifully on the other side with energy and dynamism.
However, both have been far from impressive at club level this season in stark contrast to their international teammates on the other side of the central belt. Not only that, but both Steyn and Rowe have seldom put a foot wrong when given there chance with Rowe putting in a terrific individual performance at Twickenham last Six Nations and Steyn standing out against the All Blacks in the Autumn.
That’s before you even speak about Ollie Smith and Jame Dobie who will be knocking on the door at full back and nine respectively but have also shined as wingers for Warriors of late. Will we see both Graham and van der Merwe dropped? Probably not, but don’t be surprised if at least one of them ends up playing a reduced role this tournament in favour of other options.
2. A Scotland bomb squad - could we see a 7/1 split on the bench?
Okay, hear me out, please. Obviously, even with much improved depth, the current Scotland pool doesn’t have the same ability to replace world class players with world class players the way South Africa does. What they do have is good mix of experience and promising young talent to provide cover for what should be a reasonably straightforward selection in the pack.
Not to mention the versatility of Scotland backs, many of whom are comfortable in a variety of position. Those two factors surely mean that Townsend and his staff must at least be considering the prospect of a 7/1 bench split.
Picture it for the first test against Italy in Rome. If you go with Jamie Dobie on one wing, knowing his ability to also cover nine if required, then you realistically only need Tom Jordan on the bench who can cover 10, centre and full back while Jones or Kinghorn could move to the wing if necessary.
You’ve got Gregor Brown, who should be knocking on the door of a starting place but whose versatility as a lock or back row options lends itself more to a replacement berth, ready to come on and exploit tired defenders and soft shoulders the way he does. You’ve got the experience of Sutherland and Cherry plus Darcy Rae who put in some good shifts in the last Autumn Nations Series in line to replace a predicted front three of Schoeman, Ashman and Zander Fagerson.
Gilchrist and Cummings may be a settled lock paring but the other second row men in he squad aren’t there just to make up the numbers and having someone with as many test level caps as Jonny Gray on the bench could be huge. Then you’ve got the leadership and jackaling ability of Jamie Ritchie plus the running power of Bradbury to replace Dempsey.
When you lay it all out and really think about it, I mean really stop and consider things... well it’s a bit crazy, but it just might work.
3. Half backs - a change at scrum half and the necessity of a long term 10 replacement
First of all, there is no question in my mind that Finn Russell should start all five tests at fly half if fit and available. Scotland need him on the pitch if we’re going to talk seriously about title challenges.
That being said, we will not have him forever. We know he’s around till the 2027 World Cup but he will be 35-years old when that tournament concludes.
Nobody’s saying he won’t or can’t continue beyond that, with Ireland’s Johnny Sexton playing till he was 38-years old, but just ask Wales what happens when you don’t adequately plan for the future after your star players call time on their international careers.
Townsend will need to give some thought to really testing either or both of Tom Jordan and Fergus Burke in the 10 shirt for an extended run of matches at some point. Maybe not this tournament, but that day is coming.
In terms of more immediate changes, it could be time for a serious discussion about the nine jersey. Ben White hasn’t looked back since his first cap in 2022 and that jersey has been his ever since and deservedly so based on his consistency.
Despite that, you simply cannot ignore the form of George Horne and Jamie Dobie at Glasgow. It’s a similar debate to the wingers, where Dobie is also in the conversation, but do you pick on form at club level or experience at test level.
Horne is no stranger to test rugby of course, he has 38 caps in total, but at 30-years old he has spent his whole international career as understudy to Ali Price and now White. If he’s ever going to make the Scotland nine jersey his, it feels like this is his time and this is the moment.
