Six of the most memorable portrayals of corrupt and reckless cops on film and TV

Ian Rankin has warned that crime writers are facing big questions due to changes in the way the police are now viewed around the world.

Sunday, 4th April 2021, 7:00 am

But with the Edinburgh-based author declaring that police officers are no longer seen as “knights in shining armour”, it is worth recalling some of the most memorable portrayals of bad policing in popular culture.

Filth

James McAvoy gave one of his most memorable performances as Detective Sergeant Bruce Robertson, the main protagonist in Filth, the Jon S Baird-directed adaptation of Irvine Welsh’s novel. He bullies, plots and schemes against his colleagues, while indulging in drugs, alcohol and abusive sexual relationships, before starting to experience increasingly vivid hallucinations.

Sign up to our daily newsletter

The i newsletter cut through the noise

Line of Duty

The most-talked about police drama on TV in recent years focuses on the cases being probed by an anti-corruption unit and the links between them pieced together by detectives Kate Fleming and Steve Arnott, played by Vicky McClure and Martin Compston. Created and written by Jed Mercurio, six series have been made to date.

Cracker

Jimmy McGovern’s Manchester-set ITV drama was dominated by Robbie Coltrane’s portrayal of criminal psychologist Dr Edward Fitzgerald. But one of the most memorable characters was Detective Sergeant Jimmy Beck, whose spiral of prejudice, violence and corruption culminates in the rape of a colleague.

James McAvoy starred as Detective Sergeant Bruce Robertson in Filth.

Bad Lieutenant

Harvey Keitel starred as the un-named titular character at the heart of Abel Ferrera’s crime drama, which explores the decline and downfall of a corrupt New York policer officer addicted to alcohol, drugs and gambling. He becomes increasingly embroiled with criminals as his debts mount up, while he attempts to redeem himself.

Cop Land

Sylvester Stallone had one of his strongest roles as the sheriff in a suburban New Jersey community, populated by New York City police officers, who slowly discovers the town is a front for mob connections and corruption. When he realises the extent of the wrongdoing, he decides he can no longer stand by and do nothing.

James McAvoy played a corrupt Scottish police detective in Filth.

Dirty Harry

Clint Eastwood’s iconic portrayal of San Francisco detective Harry Callahan was so successful he went on to play the character in four sequels. However, Callahan refuses to play by the book in his pursuit of serial killer, which led to critics lambasting the film as “deeply immoral” on its original release.

A message from the Editor:

Thank you for reading this article. We're more reliant on your support than ever as the shift in consumer habits brought about by coronavirus impacts our advertisers.

Martin Compston plays Steve Arnott, one of the leading investigators, in Line of Duty. Picture: Chris Barr

If you haven't already, please consider supporting our trusted, fact-checked journalism by taking out a digital subscription.

Joy Yates

Editorial Director