Complaints, refunds and anti-social behaviour on ScotRail have soared, says Lothian Tory MSP
ScotRail has seen soaring levels of complaints, refunds and anti-social behaviour on two key Edinburgh routes since it was taken into public ownership, a Lothian Tory MSP has claimed.
Miles Briggs said cancellations had also increased. He described the performance as "disappointing" and called on ministers and rail management to investigate the problems and deliver a better service.
But Transport Scotland and ScotRail hit back, saying disruption was often beyond their control, caused by a whole range of factors from adverse weather to track defects to trespassing.


They said cancellations were lower than before public ownership and also lower than most other British train operators. And they said they were investing in improved safety for passengers and staff, particularly women and girls.
Mr Briggs said figures obtained through Freedom of Information showed complaints about the Edinburgh-Glasgow service had nearly doubled from 388 in 2022 to 773 in 2024; refunds on the same route had soared from 100 in 2022 to 430 in 2024; and cases of antisocial behaviour had more than quadrupled from nine in 2023 to 37 in 2024.
And he said it was a similar picture on trains between Edinburgh and East Lothian, with complaints about the Edinburgh-Dunbar service rising from eight in 2022 to 20 in 2024, and Edinburgh-North Berwick complaints going up from 86 to 200 in the same period; while refunds more than doubled between Edinburgh and Dunbar and the North Berwick line saw a 400 per cent increase.
He said: “It is very disappointing to see ScotRail services performing this poorly on two of the most important lines to our region.
“Edinburgh and Lothian need reliable public transport links east and west. Glasgow is our biggest and closest economic neighbour while East Lothian is a rapidly growing region with very close ties to the Capital.
“This data shows that since SNP Ministers took control of ScotRail, passengers’ experience has taken a dive. It is vital that SNP Ministers, as well as senior rail management, get to the bottom of this and deliver reliable transport infrastructure for commuters to and from Edinburgh.”
ScotRail was taken into public ownership in 2022 after the Scottish Government brought the franchise with Abellio to an early end due to poor performance.
But ScotRail said the main causes of disruption and performance failures were train crew shortages and challenges with the fleet. That was why ScotRail was recruiting and training 160 drivers a year - more than any other train operator in Britain - and work was under way to improve the reliability of trains as part of a £7.5 million investment over the next couple of years.
Mark Ilderton, ScotRail Service Delivery Director, said: “ScotRail operates more than 2,100 services across the country every day, with around nine out of ten of those services meeting the punctuality target, getting customers to where they need to be.
“Disruption can be for a number of reasons, many of them outside the control of ScotRail, and we know how frustrating it is when delays or cancellations occur.
“When it does happen, it is only right that compensation is paid to customers who experience disruption to their journey. Through our Delay Repay Guarantee, anyone delayed by 30 minutes or more is entitled to claim money back through the ScotRail website or mobile app.
“We are absolutely committed to delivering the best possible service for customers throughout the country, and everyone at ScotRail is working hard to deliver the safe and reliable railway that our customers expect and deserve, and to encourage more people to travel by train instead of using the car.”
The company added it had invested considerably to improve safety on the rail network, including £1.6m to triple the number of body-worn cameras to tackle anti-social behaviour, and hiring more people to double staff late-night trains on several routes, as well as a £2m upgrade of its CCTV network and expanding its Travel Safe team.
Transport Scotland said public ownership created the opportunity for the railway to be run for the benefit of passengers, modernising it and delivering efficient and sustainable passenger services.
And it said passenger numbers were up and ScotRail's train performance and passenger satisfaction was consistently higher than the GB average.
The permanent removal of peak fares had also made rail more affordable and ticketing simpler for passengers across Scotland
A spokesperson said: “Despite severe weather events and a significant amount of disruption caused by external factors beyond ScotRail’s control, cancellations remain lower than the period immediately before public ownership.
“ScotRail performs consistently better than most other GB operators. In the year to September 2025, ScotRail cancelled just 2.1 per cent of its trains - around half as many cancellations as the GB average of 3.9 per cent.
"ScotRail’s overall performance has been around 90 per cent for the three consecutive years of ScotRail in public ownership. This is consistently higher than many GB operators."